Kentucky Board Discusses Final Accountability Data Showing Reading Gains

Kentucky’s final round of school accountability data under the current model landed in mid-October, and the numbers tell a story of genuine progress shadowed by a structural cliff edge.

The Kentucky Department of Education released the 2025-2026 assessment results on Oct. 15, showing reading scores climbing to recent highs across every tested grade and graduation rates improving across nearly all demographic groups. Yet fewer schools earned the top blue and green overall ratings, dragged down not by collapsing performance but by a stalled “Change” metric that measures year-over-year improvement.

“Kentucky students should be commended for their performance on Kentucky’s assessments,” Education Commissioner Robbie Fletcher said in the release. “There is still plenty of room for growth, but students in the Commonwealth have worked hard to master the content they have been learning, and there are many areas to be proud of.”

The data drop marks the last report card before House Bill 257 reshapes the accountability system entirely starting in the 2026-2027 school year, a transition the Kentucky Board of Education digested during its virtual meeting on Nov. 4.

Reading gains show literacy investment results

Reading gains were the clearest bright spot. Associate Commissioner Jennifer Stafford told the board that novice rates — the percentage of students scoring at the lowest performance level — declined across multiple areas, and the statewide push around the “science of reading” appears to be paying dividends.

Kentucky Board Discusses Final Accountability Data Showing Reading Gains

Chief Academic Officer Micki Marinelli detailed a literacy infrastructure built over several years: the Language Essentials for Teachers of Reading and Spelling (LETRS) professional learning, a statewide coaching model placing school-based literacy coaches in high-need buildings, and the Kentucky Early Literacy Leadership Network engaging 82 districts across three cohorts.

“That’s exactly what we want to see, and those schools are working extremely hard to address student needs, and they have reported the impact of coaching and the support that’s being provided,” Marinelli told the board.

House Bill 253, passed in 2026, now requires all K-5 educators to complete KDE-approved science of reading professional learning by June 30, 2029. The department recently added the AIM Institute for Learning & Research’s Pathways to Proficient Reading as a third approved pathway.

Math programs expand while outcomes lag

Mathematics outcomes are harder to read. The Kentucky Center for Mathematics’ K-5 Numeracy Counts Academy and PIMSER’s Numeracy Counts Administrator Academy launched in 2025, with 144 districts participating in various numeracy programs.

A Mathematics Leadership Collaborative for grades 4-8 brought 24 districts into its first cohort, with a second cohort targeting a Jan. 2027 launch — though a third cohort in 2027-2028 will require new funding beyond the current Council of Chief State School Officers grant.

“We want to see continual growth in mathematics outcomes. We want to see progress,” Marinelli said. “And if we’re not making gains and reducing those achievement gaps, we need to do more to better support our schools and districts in addressing those needs.”

Science performance increased compared to prior years, particularly at elementary and high school levels, but board member Randy Poe pressed for more urgency.

“I think all the other data is all great, so that’s good; let’s celebrate those improvements and what’s really working, but I think as a board or as KDE, one of the things we really need to dig into is science,” Poe said during the meeting.

Social studies results were flat, and writing performance was mixed across grade levels — the 2025-2026 administration was the last year for separate editing and mechanics and on-demand writing assessments.

The accountability cliff: why top ratings shrank

The current system, established after 2020 revisions to KRS 158.6455, evaluates schools on “Status” (current-year performance) and “Change” (year-over-year progress) across state indicators. Schools receive color-coded overall ratings: blue, green, yellow, orange, red.

Status scores held relatively steady in 2025-2026. But Change scores dropped sharply, meaning schools improved less than they had the year before. The result: fewer blue and green schools, more yellow and orange, even though absolute performance didn’t decline.

Level Year Blue Green Yellow Orange Red
High 2025 46 86 66 21 9
High 2026 38 75 83 23 9

The shift matters because the 2026-2027 system under HB 257 will use different calculations and indicators entirely. KDE officials warned that comparing future results to this fall’s release will be apples-to-oranges.

Intervention lists and the road ahead

Associate Commissioner Kelly Foster briefed the board on schools identified for federal intervention under the Every Student Succeeds Act, and how KDE’s Office of Continuous Improvement and Support coordinates with Teaching and Learning to target professional development at those buildings.

Fletcher, who began his career as a math and science teacher at Inez Middle School after graduating from Morehead State University in 1996, returned a decade later to lead his alma mater, Sheldon Clark High School, as principal in 2009–2010.

He spent the next ten years as superintendent of Lawrence County Schools before the Kentucky Senate confirmed him as Commissioner of Education on April 15, 2024 — the first commissioner confirmed under the new Senate Bill 107 process — and he assumed office on July 1.

For now, the 2025-2026 data stands as the final benchmark of an era. The next release will measure a different system, built on the Kentucky United We Learn Council’s vision — and the first real test of whether the literacy and numeracy investments can sustain momentum under a new accountability framework.