Chicago Animal Rights Activist Jailed for False Shooting Report at Illinois Rodeo

Ogle County Associate Judge Anthony Peska sentenced Chicago animal rights activist Jodie Wiederkehr, 57, to 30 days in jail and 12 months of probation Wednesday for falsely reporting a shooting at a rodeo near Rochelle in May 2025.

A jury convicted Wiederkehr in June of disorderly conduct, a Class 4 felony, and telephone harassment, a Class B misdemeanor, after a two-day trial. Peska imposed the sentence during a hearing that had been postponed from July. With day-for-day good-behavior credit, the 60-day sentence would translate into 30 days.

The case sits at the intersection of rural law-enforcement limits and a fight over “steer tailing,” a rodeo event in which a horseback rider chases a steer, wraps its tail around a leg and yanks the animal to the ground — sometimes tearing the tail clean off, a trauma known as degloving.

Three men were convicted of animal cruelty in August for injuring a steer during that event, yet Illinois has no statute that explicitly bans steer tailing statewide.

“I apologize and I regret making a false statement,” Wiederkehr told the court Wednesday, her voice cracking as she described recently breaking her own wrist and feeling a glimpse of what the animals endure. “I will never apologize for fighting for those that don’t have a voice.”

Jodie Wiederkehr tears up while delivering a statement Wednesday, Nov. 4, 2026, at her sentencing in Ogle County Court
Photo: shawlocal.com

The 27 calls that forced the issue

Prosecutors said Wiederkehr phoned the Ogle County Sheriff’s non-emergency line 27 times on May 25, 2025, while monitoring the rodeo via drone with a team from SHARK — SHowing Animals Respect and Kindness. Frustrated that deputies would not respond to reports of animal cruelty, she told two dispatchers she had witnessed a shooting in the 16000 block of Ritchie Road, south of Rochelle. No shooting had occurred.

“There were steers being degloved, overworked, criminally abused,” Wiederkehr testified at trial. She said she called repeatedly because “each time I called there was a crime happening” that amounted to animal cruelty, but was not taken seriously.

Animal rights activist sentenced for case involving 20 calls to 911 in Ogle County — Rockford News First

Ogle County Assistant State’s Attorney Matthew Leiston recommended 24 months of probation and “some jail time.” Defense attorneys Brad Thomson and Chris Carraway sought a conditional discharge, citing Wiederkehr’s lack of criminal history and the context of her advocacy. Thomson called any incarceration “excessive” and said the conviction itself was lesson enough.

Judge weighs deterrence against character

Peska acknowledged character letters portraying Wiederkehr as “a coveted family member, friend, advocate.” Still, he said a custodial sentence was necessary to deter false reports in a county where, on a given shift, two deputies might cover the entire county.

“When you call the Ogle County sheriff’s department, they might have two deputies on duty for the entire county,” Peska said from the bench. “A bogus call can take them away from a legitimate emergency.”

Midwest animal rights activist jailed for falsely reporting sh
Photo: ameriledger.com

The judge also barred a necessity defense — the argument that Wiederkehr broke the law to prevent greater harm — and excluded video of the rodeo, ruling the trial was about the false report, not the legitimacy of steer tailing. Carraway told Shaw Local he was “shocked” by the jail term and confirmed an appeal will be filed on the sentence, the conviction, or both.

Prosecutor denies vindictive motive

Wiederkehr’s filings alleged vindictive prosecution, noting her prior public criticism of State’s Attorney Mike Rock for declining to charge rodeo organizers. Rock rejected the claim. “Our prosecution, in every case, is to pursue justice, and that’s what was done here,” he said.

“She wasn’t treated worse or better because of who she was … she committed a criminal act and we pursued it.” Rock added he believed jail was appropriate; the felony statute allowed up to three years in prison.

Defense attorneys highlighted a contrast: Peska previously gave a teenager who threatened to “shoot up” a school 24 months of probation.

Rodeo ends, legal fight continues

Under pressure, organizers of the Ogle County rodeo stopped holding the event in July. Yet the broader legal gap remains: steer tailing is banned in some states, but Illinois law still relies on general cruelty statutes that some say are difficult to apply.

SHARK President Steve Hindi told the Daily Mail that “practically every Illinois humane law has been violated in Ogle County” and that state’s attorneys in every other county with steer tailing have taken action except Ogle County.