One Night in Idaho: Catching a Killer Premieres Dec. 28 on Prime Video

Amazon MGM Studios has set a December 28, 2026 premiere for One Night in Idaho: Catching a Killer, a three-episode second season that picks up where the first documentary left off — this time from inside the investigation that caught Bryan Kohberger, The Hollywood Reporter reported.

In 2022, Kohberger brutally stabbed and killed Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin and Xana Kernodle in their Moscow, Idaho rental home. The murders triggered a pair of competing documentaries released eight days apart; Prime Video’s One Night in Idaho: The College Murders arrived first, followed by Peacock’s The Idaho Student Murders.

What distinguishes this chapter is access. Director Matthew Galkin and showrunner Katie A. King secured first-time, on-camera interviews with the detectives and federal agents who built the case — many of whom were bound by a gag order until Kohberger’s conviction.

The participant list reads like an organizational chart of the investigation: Moscow Police lead detective Brett Payne and his wife Alyson, Idaho State Police lead detective Darren Gilbertson, former Moscow Police Chief James Fry, first responding officers Mitch Nunes and Shaine Gunderson, FBI agents Jon Habben and Joe Traino, and Pennsylvania State Police Major Chris Paris.

One Night in Idaho: Catching a Killer Premieres Dec. 28 on Prime Video
Photo: yahoo.com

Habben, based in Los Angeles, is credited with cracking the case through investigative genetic genealogy. Traino went undercover as a garbage collector in Pennsylvania to obtain familial DNA from the Kohberger household trash. Paris orchestrated the tactical arrest operation. None of them have appeared in previous documentaries on the case, Amazon MGM Studios confirmed to The Hollywood Reporter.

The procedural timeline matters here. Season one was conceived as a limited series. The greenlight for a follow-up came only after Kohberger entered a guilty plea to four counts of first-degree murder — a plea he later attempted to withdraw. The court denied that motion, and Kohberger is now serving four consecutive life sentences without parole at the Idaho Maximum Security Institution.

One Night in Idaho: Catching a Killer – Official Trailer — Prime Video

Production credentials signal the project’s ambition. Liz Garbus, an Oscar nominee and Emmy winner for I’ll Be Gone in the Dark, co-directed season one with Galkin and returns as executive producer through her Story Syndicate banner. James Patterson Entertainment, Paramount Television Studios and Fairhaven round out the producing consortium. Galkin directs solo this season; King serves as showrunner.

For viewers, the December 28 date offers a concrete entry point. Season one remains on Prime Video for catch-up. The second season promises to bridge the investigative mechanics — genetic genealogy, surveillance, the Pennsylvania trash pull — with the emotional aftermath for the victims’ families, several of whom participated in the first season.

One Night in Idaho Catching a Killer
Photo: seat42f.com

Whether that access yields new insight or simply a more polished procedural narrative will be the test when the three episodes drop on December 28.