Chicago theater critics have published the 2026 holiday guide as the city enjoys an unusually mild November, offering ten productions that range from a 49th annual Dickens staple to a Blue Man Group comeback under Cirque du Soleil ownership.
Chris Jones, writing for the Chicago Tribune, framed the list around a simple premise: some audiences want explicitly seasonal fare, and the market has splintered into distinct lanes — traditional pageantry, family interactive shows, irreverent parody, and homegrown experimental work. The result is a calendar that stretches from late November into early January across venues from the Loop to Aurora and Andersonville.
Two Carols, two different beasts
The Goodman Theatre enters its 49th year of A Christmas Carol — the 50th anniversary looms in 2027 — with Steppenwolf ensemble member Tim Hopper taking over the Scrooge role vacated by Larry Yando, who spent the year touring in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.
Director Malkia Stampley returns for her second edition, backed by three new ghosts: Rae Gray (Christmas Past), Lachrisa Grandberry (Present) and Gavin Lawrence (Marley). Eleven-year-old Sanjana Suraj makes her debut as Tiny Tim. The production runs through Dec. 31 at 170 N. Dearborn St.
Twenty miles west, the Paramount Theatre in Aurora is mounting an all-new version written and directed by staff member Trent Stork. Michael Moreland Milligan plays Scrooge in what Jones described as an expansive, pageant-like show with a huge cast, live music, special effects including snow, and an Instagram-ready tree in the historic lobby.
The Paramount run extends through Jan. 3, 2027, and the theater has signaled this is likely a one-off before returning to its regular Broadway musical programming.
Blue Man Group returns to Loop
After a 27-year run at the Briar Street Theatre that ended in January 2025, Blue Man Group is back in Chicago for a limited holiday engagement at the CIBC Theatre in the Loop, Nov. 24 through Dec. 13.
The founding fathers have sold the property to Cirque du Soleil Entertainment Group, which is rolling out the same seasonal push in Boston and New York. The Briar Street building itself is slated for a condo development. Jones noted the CIBC location is convenient for State Street shopping and the downtown holiday market, making it a practical pick for multi-generational families.
American Blues Theater’s It’s a Wonderful Life: Live in Chicago enters its 25th year with a new George Bailey: Michael Mahler steps into the role after 16 years as the production’s primary musician. Director Gwendolyn Whiteside remains at the helm.
Jones, who recently saw the Broadway version of the same title, wrote that the American Blues take is “a lot more fun and the prices are a fraction of what you’d pay in New York City.” It runs through Dec. 27 at 5627 N. Lincoln Ave.
For audiences allergic to sentiment, Hell in a Handbag Productions offers It’s a Horrible Life: A Golden Girls Lost Episodes Musical Parody at Theater Wit, Dec. 3 through Jan. 3, 2027. David Cerda stars as Dorothy in a meta-disaster that spirals into an It’s a Wonderful Life audition gone wrong. The company, now in its 25th year, specializes in what Jones called “campery with bells on.”
Small stages, big swings
Griffin Theatre Company revives The House Without a Christmas Tree at Theater Wit through Dec. 27. Bill Massolia’s musical, based on the 1972 TV movie novelized by Gail Rock, is set in 1946 Clear River, Nebraska. Jones caught the 2024 Andersonville premiere and found “unrealized promise,” comparing the plot to a Midwest Secret Garden. The company hopes additional workshopping has sharpened the piece.
Chicago Children’s Theatre brings back The Beatrix Potter Holiday Party, a trunk-and-puppet show aimed at ages eight and under, Dec. 5–27 at 100 S. Racine Ave. The interactive format encourages rambunctious participation and includes a “festive holiday spread” — cookies included.
Manual Cinema returns to the Studebaker Theater in the Fine Arts Building, Dec. 18–27, with its mixed-media Christmas Carol — an original story, not the Dickens text — blending live music, handmade puppets, film and shadow play. The company premiered a film at the Obama Presidential Center this year and has cemented its Studebaker relationship, a hopeful sign for a permanent downtown holiday fixture.
Jessie Mueller, a Chicago native with a Tony for Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, headlines a two-night holiday cabaret Dec. 18–19 at Steppenwolf’s Downstairs Theatre, accompanied by music director Seth Rudetsky and produced by Mark Cortale. Mueller will originate the role of Mrs. Brown in Paddington the Musical on Broadway this spring.
Rounding out the list, The Unauthorized Hallmark(ish) Parody Musical lands at the Broadway Playhouse Dec. 8–13. The Canadian touring show, with creatives including Bonnie Milligan, sends up the cable network’s formula with songs like “Judge that Cookie!” and “Feels Like Christmas (Because It’s Literally Christmas).” Jones observed that Hallmark movies — this year’s slate includes Holiday Touchdown: a Bears Love Story — are arguably self-parodies already.
The Paramount Theatre in Aurora opened in 1931 as the first air-conditioned building constructed outside Chicago, commissioned for one million dollars by J. J. Rubens and designed by Rapp and Rapp.
It debuted with appearances by the Marx Brothers, Jack Benny, Jeanette MacDonald, and Burns and Allen. The venue closed for renovation in 1976 and reopened on April 19, 1978, after its sale to the Aurora Civic Center Authority; it was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1980.
Non-holiday alternatives
For audiences skipping the seasonal theme entirely, Jones flagged Little Shop of Horrors at the Biograph Theatre, Heroes of the Fourth Turning at A Red Orchid Theatre, and Vape! The Grease Parody at the Apollo — one of the few shows running the week between Christmas and New Year. David Byrne’s immersive Theater of the Mind continues in the Loop through Jan. 17, 2027.