Coleman: Gov Not to Require AI Labels in FAIR News Act

“The government may not commandeer a newsroom’s editorial discretion to advance its own vision of responsible journalism,” said Coleman, legislative counsel for AI and free expression at the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE).

New York newsrooms could face government investigation if the Fundamental Artificial Intelligence Requirements in News Act (FAIR News Act) is signed into law, as the state seeks to safeguard the “integrity of the news” by requiring warning labels on content substantially created using generative artificial intelligence at https://www.nydailynews.com/2026/11/22/albany-shouldnt-police-newsrooms-ai-use/.

The bill, which awaits Gov. Hochul’s signature, applies to images, video, and audio, as well as plain text, published across newspapers, websites, newsletters, podcasts, and other forms of news programming.

These required labels must appear at the very top of the content, the same location journalists typically use for their most compelling material.

Coleman, legislative counsel for AI and free expression at the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), stated, “The government may not commandeer a newsroom’s editorial discretion to advance its own vision of responsible journalism.”

If the government requires a warning label for an editorial method it deems unreliable, there could be a requirement for a warning label on all stories using anonymous sources.

The potential for government oversight extends beyond AI, raising questions about mandatory labeling for stories using anonymous sources or investigative reports relying on leaked documents.

The Sedition Act of 1798, which made it a crime to publish false and malicious writings against the government, previously empowered politicians to decide what news was fit to print, a situation that provoked fierce backlash when the Adams’ administration used it to prosecute newspaper editors.

The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression broadened its mission beyond college campuses to encompass freedom of speech throughout American society in June 2022. This shift included a $75 million expansion plan over three years to focus on research, public education, and litigation.

Editorial decisions belong to newsrooms, which answer to their readers, not the government.