Colorado Schools Scramble to Interpret Proposition 134 After State Guidance

Colorado voters approved Proposition 134 this month requiring school athletic teams to be designated by biological sex, prompting districts to scramble over interpretation after state guidance.

Colorado school districts are scrambling to interpret a new voter-approved sports law that takes effect January 1, 2027, after state guidance said schools are not required to verify a student’s biological sex through DNA testing, medical records or physical exams, KDVR reported.

The Colorado Department of Education issued guidance acknowledging the law’s requirements but emphasizing that districts should not conduct visual inspections, demand genetic testing or question students about “intimate medical information,” CBS News Colorado reported. The department also said that remaining questions may be resolved through future litigation or legislation.

Proposition 134, approved by voters this month, requires school-based athletic teams from elementary through collegiate levels to be designated male, female or coeducational based on biological sex as defined in the measure. The law restricts transgender students from playing on teams that do not match their biological sex under that definition.

Colorado Schools Scramble to Interpret Proposition 134 After State Guidance
Photo: cbsnews.com

CDE’s guidance says schools may reasonably trust students and their parents or guardians to comply.

Legal expert notes conflicts with privacy protections

Tim Holbrook, a professor of law at the University of Denver Sturm College of Law, said schools must now fit the new requirements alongside existing laws that protect student privacy and guard against harassment. He pointed to federal protections and the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act as part of the legal framework schools must consider.

Prop 134 guidance says schools shouldn't verify students' sex; proponents respond — CBS Colorado

Tim Holbrook, professor of law, University of Denver Sturm College of Law

Holbrook said the law relies heavily on students and families acting in good faith and does not create a private right of action to challenge an individual student’s eligibility. Because the ballot initiative is a statute and not a constitutional amendment, the legislature could also have a role in determining how it gets implemented, he said.

Opposing reactions

Protect Kids Colorado, the group behind the measure, said it has serious concerns about guidance issued less than two weeks after the election that appears to undermine meaningful implementation. “Implementation does not need to be complicated or invasive. Schools already maintain student records, and student-athletes routinely undergo sports physicals.”

Z Williams, director of the Bread and Roses Legal Center, told CBS News Colorado the guidance shows the measure cannot be enforced. “What we see here is further indication that 134 was unenforceable from the beginning.”

District-level decisions ahead

The Colorado Education Association, the state’s largest union of educators, opposed Proposition 134 because it targets transgender youth for exclusion and threatens the privacy of all students. President Kevin Vick said the union remains concerned about how the measure harms both students and educators but is grateful that state leaders are protecting basic civil and privacy rights.

Protect Kids Colorado, the group behind Proposition 134, is a conservative advocacy organization that state records link to three 2026 ballot measures: Propositions 133, 134 and 135. Those initiatives address child sex trafficking penalties, school sports team designations based on biological sex, and restrictions on gender-affirming care for minors.

The organization operates alongside Advance Colorado, which is tied to eight other measures on the same ballot. A Colorado Times Recorder investigation published in August 2025 traced millions of dollars through donor-advised funds and organizations connected to this network, though Protect Kids Colorado’s specific funding sources were not itemized in the review of IRS Form 990 filings.

Everything won’t happen overnight. Districts will have time to work through the changes and get them in place.