Johnston Voters Reject Eminent Domain Charter Amendment; Town Vows to Seize Land Anyway

Johnston voters rejected a charter amendment that would have cleared the way for the town to seize 31 acres for a municipal complex, yet the council president says the taking will proceed anyway under a different state law.

The vote on Nov. 3 was 4,761 against the amendment to 4,090 for it — 54 percent to 46 percent — with 9,894 of the town’s 24,015 registered voters casting ballots, according to unofficial vote counts. The measure was meant to fix the constitutional defects a federal judge found in the town’s first attempt to condemn the land.

“Johnston voters sent a clear message that they don’t want to give the town more powers to take land,” said Kady Valois, an attorney with Pacific Legal Foundation, which represents the property owners. “But despite the public’s rejection of these eminent domain efforts, the Town is still trying to take the Santoros’ land to prevent them from developing affordable housing on their own land.”

Ralph Santoro, his wife Suzanne, his sister Lucille and their childhood friend Salvatore “Sal” Compagnone have assembled the parcel off George Waterman Road over nearly 40 years. They propose 252 income‑restricted apartments on the 31 acres — a project the town’s own 2004 Comprehensive Community Plan identified as a prime site for affordable housing. The owners say they have long kept rents well below market to give lower‑income families a foothold.

When Rhode Island streamlined affordable‑housing approvals statewide in 2024, the group moved forward with permitting. Mayor Joseph Polisena Jr. responded by vowing to “use all the power of government that I have to stop it,” adding that if the owners built market‑rate suburban homes instead, “the Town w[ould] roll out the red carpet to guide you through the planning process and see the project to completion.”

The town condemned the property in 2024, claiming it needed the site for a new police and fire station. The owners sued in March 2025, calling it a “sham taking” designed solely to block the apartments.

In July 2026, U.S. District Judge Melissa DuBose agreed, ruling that the town charter lacked the funding guarantees and enforcement mechanisms the Constitution requires for eminent domain. She noted the town could still pursue the land under other state statutes — specifically the Rhode Island Municipal Public Buildings Authority Law.

Amendment eminent domain l

Rather than accept the ruling, the council placed a charter amendment on the November ballot to supply the missing pieces. Voters said no. Mayor Polisena told the Johnston SunRise he accepts the result and that “voters expressed their desire to build 252 low‑income apartment units.”

Council President Robert Russo told the same paper the rejection is not an impediment — the town will use the Municipal Public Buildings Authority instead. “If the ballot question fails, we have another way to use eminent domain,” Russo said.

“We can either withdraw or use the MPBA.”

Mayor Joseph Polisena Jr., email to the Providence Journal

The federal lawsuit continues. The owners’ lawyers argue the Municipal Public Buildings Authority cannot be used as a pretext to block a lawful private development, especially after the town’s own voters refused to endorse the taking. Pacific Legal Foundation says it will keep fighting to protect the property. No hearing date on the next phase has been set.