Colts’ Steichen Sticking With Daniel Jones as QB; Anthony Richardson on Scout Team

Indianapolis Colts coach Shane Steichen is sticking with Daniel Jones as his starting quarterback despite Jones ranking last among NFL starters in QBR and yards per attempt, while former No. 4 overall pick Anthony Richardson runs the scout team, ESPN reported.

The Colts head into Thursday night’s AFC South matchup against the Houston Texans with a quarterback posting a 30.3 QBR and a league-leading 12 interceptions. Jones has averaged just 135 passing yards over his last four games and hasn’t thrown for 200 yards in a month. His 1.7 QBR in Sunday’s win over Miami was the worst by any starter this season, yet Steichen said he evaluates “everything” on film before considering a change.

The grace gap between two quarterbacks

Steichen’s patience with Jones stands in sharp contrast to his handling of Richardson. The coach benched Richardson midway through the 2024 season after the quarterback kneeled on the field during a game in Houston, saying he was exhausted. Steichen turned to Joe Flacco, then returned to Richardson three weeks later. Now Richardson, in the final year of his rookie contract, can’t get on the field even as the team spirals.

Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson (5) takes off his helmet before a preseason NFL football game against
Photo: tsn.ca

“It’s not all about one guy,” Steichen said this week. “I think it takes all 11 to do their job at a high level.” That level of collective accountability wasn’t extended to Richardson, whose 50.9 percent career completion rate and injury history appeared to erode the coach’s confidence. The Colts signed Jones the following offseason and handed him a two-year, $88 million extension.

A roster stripped to the bone

Context matters. General manager Chris Ballard was fired on October 19. Since then, the Colts have traded away receivers Josh Downs and Keenan Allen and All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson. The team has lost five of six and sits four games behind Jacksonville in the division. Jones has a 7-to-12 touchdown-to-interception ratio and 13 fumbles in 23 starts as a Colt.

Defensive end Jaylahn Tuimoloau sees Richardson’s upside daily. “He’s so explosive,” Tuimoloau said. “I don’t think I’ve ever played against a quarterback that explosive. He gives us great looks on the scout team whenever we go against him.” Nose tackle Grover Stewart, a 314-pound veteran, echoes that: “He’s a hard guy to catch. He’s fast. That’s a threat right there. Big arm, big legs.”

Richardson’s uncertain future

Richardson requested a trade earlier this year, according to team sources, but nothing materialized. He was recently cited for marijuana possession in Carmel, Indiana, and faces a possible four-game suspension under the personal conduct policy, though there’s no indication that factors into the lineup decision.

“I’ve just got to keep doing what I’ve been doing, coming in the building, showing up to work,” Richardson said. “Just preparing like I was going to be the starter regardless of what decision [Steichen] makes.”

The Indianapolis Colts, founded in 1953 in Baltimore before relocating to Indiana in 1984, are one of three original NFL teams that joined former AFL clubs to form the AFC after the 1970 merger. Since 1987, the organization has hosted the NFL Scouting Combine, the league’s premier annual player evaluation event.

Steichen has acknowledged Richardson’s rushing ability — 10 touchdowns in 15 career starts — could provide a spark and confirmed a package of plays exists for him. Yet the Colts haven’t used it. With Steichen’s job security thinning and the season slipping away, the question shifts from whether Richardson plays to whether he ever plays for Indianapolis again.