Nassau County is putting $1 million toward saving the St. Paul’s main building, but a village letter writer says taxpayers are still on the hook for nearly $9 million more.
The grant, announced by County Executive Bruce Blakeman and St. Paul’s Conservancy co-chairs Frank McDonough and Peter Coll, is meant to advance phased restoration of the 1883 High Victorian Gothic landmark, Long Island Business News reported.
Designed by William Harris in memory of Garden City founder Alexander T. Stewart at his widow Cornelia’s request, the building has sat on the National Register of Historic Places since 1978 and landed on the Preservation League of New York State’s “Seven to Save” endangered list in 2003.
“Preserving Long Island’s history means saving great architecture,” Blakeman said in a written statement. “Like Long Island’s historic Gold Coast mansions, the St. Paul’s Main Building requires restoration. Similar to other historic Long Island sites, such as Bethpage Village, this structure reminds Long Islanders of our storied past and points the way to our dynamic future.”
The Conservancy said the county money will be “supplemented and exceeded by local philanthropy,” according to a joint statement from Honorary Co-Chair Robert Catell and McDonough. But a letter published in Garden City News paints a sharply different financial picture.
“The BOT wants to establish an $8.7 million plus interest for a 15 year bond without taxpayers’ consent or authorization, which should be done through a bond resolution. Now we add in the $220,000 donation by the society, it now totals $8,920,000 which will be going towards the project for exterior repairs.”
— Bob Orosz, letter to Garden City News
Orosz wrote that the Garden City Landmark Society, formed in May 2026 to use private philanthropy and grants to offset rising village debt and property taxes, presented $220,000 in donations to the Board of Trustees on November 5. That amount represents roughly 2.5 percent of the $8.92 million project total he cites, leaving village taxpayers responsible for 100 percent of the $8.7 million bond principal plus interest over 15 years.
The Village of Garden City bought the campus from the Episcopal Diocese in 1993, taking ownership of the main building and several other structures. The Conservancy’s phased restoration plan has been in discussion for years; Blakeman noted he had been working on the grant with McDonough and Catell for “the past few years.”
Orosz’s letter argues the Landmark Society’s fundraising has barely dented the public burden. “So much for their financial strategies and objectives in eliminating taxpayer burdens,” he wrote.
Nassau County, the affluent suburban county immediately east of New York City on Long Island, was formed in 1899 when three eastern towns seceded from Queens County after its western portion became a borough of New York City.
The county’s population reached 1,395,774 in the 2020 census, making it the sixth-largest in New York State. Its name derives from an old name for Long Island itself, honoring the Dutch House of Nassau, and its orange and blue county colors match those of the House of Orange-Nassau.
The county grant covers about 11 percent of the $8.92 million figure Orosz cites. The Conservancy insists private giving will exceed the public contribution, but the letter suggests the bond — if approved without a voter referendum — would lock in decades of repayment for a building that has been endangered for over two decades.