Crew Coach Says Messi Should Have Seen Red in 3-0 Playoff Win Over Miami

Columbus Crew’s 3-0 win at Nu Stadium on Saturday puts Inter Miami one defeat from a first-round playoff exit.

The defending MLS Cup champions, seeded second in the Eastern Conference, must win Game 2 in Columbus on Friday to force a deciding Game 3 back in Miami on December 2, ESPN reported. A red card for Lionel Messi in Game 1 would have suspended him for that match.

Messi threw the ball into the face of Gonzalo Tapia from a few feet away during first-half stoppage time after Tapia did not retreat the required distance on a throw-in. Referee Allen Chapman showed yellow cards to both players.

“Everyone knows that was more than a yellow card,” Crew head coach Laurent Courtois told reporters after the match. “It’s just really sad.”

Chapman defended the decision to a pool reporter, saying “the force used was negligible, and the offence did not reach the level of violent conduct,” according to flashscore.com. Al Jazeera noted that under International Football Association Board Law 12, a throw-in striking an opponent warrants a yellow card for unsporting behaviour, with a red card only if excessive force is used.

Tapia, who scored twice for Columbus, declined to judge the call.

“It’s a play in the match. I don’t know if it’s a red card, but I am not the referee to say. It stays there,” he told ESPN.

Inter Miami played the final 54 minutes with 10 men after defender Gonzalo Luján received a second yellow card in the 36th minute, nasrcoresports.my.id reported. Tapia opened the scoring from the penalty spot in the ninth minute after goalkeeper Dayne St. Clair brought him down.

Taha Habroune made it 2-0 in the 52nd minute, and Tapia added his second in the 58th.

Miami co-owner Jorge Mas presented Messi with the 2026 Golden Boot before kickoff. The Argentine scored 26 goals with 17 assists in the regular season, becoming the first player to win the award in consecutive seasons, ESPN reported.

“We didn’t produce the great performance we had hoped for. Everything went wrong, but we have to learn from it because next time, if we don’t win, we’re out,” Miami head coach Cristian “Kily” González told reporters.

Inter Miami head coach Cristian “Kily” González said the yellow card shown to Messi “doesn’t change much” and that the team cannot blame the referee, adding that officials sometimes make mistakes and sometimes “don’t like each one of us,” according to ESPN. Crew coach Laurent Courtois repeated his view that “everyone knows that was more than a yellow card” and called the situation “sad,” according to Flashscore.

González also told reporters after the match that the team created four or five clear-cut chances but failed to convert, and that the red card shown to Gonzalo Luján “completely changed the nature of the match,” NasrCoreSports reported. He added that he takes “full responsibility” for the result.

Al Jazeera noted that under International Football Association Board Law 12, a throw-in striking an opponent warrants a yellow card for unsporting behaviour, with a red card only if excessive force is used. Chapman’s explanation aligned with that guidance.