D.C. and New York City Reach Record High Safety Perceptions While Seattle and Minneapolis Hit Record Lows

Washington, D.C. is now considered safe by 64% of Americans, the highest rating for the nation’s capital since Gallup began tracking the metric in 1990.

This surge marks a 12-percentage-point increase since 2023, a shift that stands in stark contrast to the declining safety perceptions seen in several other major American hubs. While the capital’s reputation has climbed, New York City has also seen its safety rating reach a new peak, rising six points to 47%.

The latest data, derived from an Oct. 1-19 Gallup poll reveals divided urban perceptions. While cities like Miami and Los Angeles are matching their previous highs, other major metropolitan areas are being viewed less favorably by the public.

Minneapolis and Seattle, which had high safety ratings in 1990, have seen their safety ratings tumble to their lowest levels since 1990. Between 1993 and 2006, at least 70% of Americans routinely viewed both cities as safe, but that consensus has evaporated.

Perhaps the most striking element of the report is not just how safe cities are perceived to be, but how those perceptions have become deeply polarized. In the decades following 1990, the gap between how Democrats and Republicans viewed city safety was relatively narrow, rarely exceeding 11 percentage points.

That stability vanished by 2023, and the 2026 data shows that the rift remains substantial. In cities like San Francisco, Seattle, New York, and Minneapolis, Democrats are at least 40 points more likely than Republicans to label the cities as safe.

Washington, D.C., however, has emerged as a unique outlier in this political trend. In 2023, there was a 48-point gap between Democrats (77%) and Republicans (29%) regarding the capital’s safety. Today, that gap has narrowed to seven points, with 63% of Republicans and 70% of Democrats calling it safe.

This sudden shift in Republican sentiment appears linked to specific federal interventions. The data suggests the change may be a response to the Trump administration’s deployment of National Guard troops and federal law enforcement personnel to the District starting in August 2025.

The following table tracks the current perceived safety levels reported by Gallup:

City Current Safety Rating (%) Trend Context
Washington, D.C. 64% Highest since 1990
Las Vegas 64% Higher than prior 58% and 61% readings
Seattle 63% Ties previous low from 2023
Miami 56% Matches 2023 high
New York City 47% New high for the city
New Orleans 47% Down from 55% in 2023
Los Angeles 42% Matches 2023 high
Chicago 39% 12-point improvement since 2023
Detroit 31% Second to last among 16 cities

Chicago’s trajectory is particularly notable. After seeing its safety rating climb from 26% in 1990 to a peak of 53% in the early 2000s, it plummeted to 27% in 2023. While its current 39% rating represents a 12-point recovery, it is still near the bottom of the list.

Perceptions of safety in cities like Seattle or Minneapolis have reached their lowest levels since 1990.

Ultimately, the data suggests that the American perception of the city is in a state of flux, moving away from the universal consensus of the early 2000s toward a more fragmented, politically charged reality.