Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani announced 16 judicial appointments and reappointments to New York City’s Criminal and Family Courts today, initiating a rigorous public vetting process for the bench.
The list, which includes 10 new judges and six reappointments, follows a standardized review by the Mayor’s Advisory Committee on the Judiciary (MACJ), an entity currently increasing its transparency and independence.
These appointments arrive at a time when the efficiency and equity of the city’s lower courts are under intense scrutiny. For the average New Yorker, these roles—often operating out of the public eye—carry profound weight.
Whether it is a Family Court judge deciding on child custody or a Criminal Court judge presiding over an arraignment, these individuals hold the power to dictate the immediate trajectory of a citizen’s life.
“The decisions made in our courts can change the course of a New Yorker’s life. That is why the people entrusted with serving on the bench must bring the highest standards of fairness, integrity and accountability to their work,” said Mayor Mamdani. The appointments are scheduled for a public hearing on November 17, 2026, marking a critical step in the confirmation process established by Executive Order 6.
A New Standard for Judicial Vetting
The current administration has made visible efforts to reform how these candidates are selected. In October, the Mayor appointed Douglas Keith as the Executive Director of the MACJ, accompanied by the implementation of a publicly available Code of Conduct for judicial candidates. The committee has also formalized the advisory role of the New York City Bar Association to insulate the selection process from political influence.

“The judges that Mayor Mamdani just named underwent an extensive vetting process and demonstrated the highest standards of integrity and competence.”
said Ramzi Kassem, Chief Counsel to the Mayor and City Hall. He emphasized that the administration aims to ensure that the judiciary reflects the diversity of the city at large, providing a standard of dignity for those appearing in court.
The Appointees: A Mix of Prosecution and Defense
The new roster draws from a broad spectrum of legal backgrounds, balancing those with extensive prosecutorial experience against those who have spent their careers in public defense. In the Criminal Court category, the appointees include Alexis Flyer, a principal court attorney at the Kings County Supreme Court, and Molly Gallivan, a senior homicide attorney at Brooklyn Defender Services.
Hana Kim, a veteran of the Queens District Attorney’s Office with over 15 years of service, joins William Kendall of the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem and Melissa Medilien, associate counsel at the Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
The Family Court appointments reflect a similar depth of experience, focused heavily on child welfare and family law. Mary Cheng, Brian Holbrook, Beth Krause, Deana Tietjen, and Danielle Rodriguez have been named to the Family Court bench. Each brings years of specialized practice, ranging from immigration law and child advocacy to previous roles as court attorney-referees.
Stability and Continuity
The six reappointments aim to maintain stability within the existing court structure. Among those remaining on the bench are Judge Tamiko Amaker, an administrative judge in New York City Criminal Court who was first appointed by Mayor Michael Bloomberg in 2010, and Judge Valentina Morales, who currently presides over an alternative-to-incarceration part in New York County. Other reappointed judges include Toni Cimino, Jennifer Saint-Preux, Joseph Sorrentino, and Juanita E. Wing.
While the administration touts these selections as a step toward a more effective system, the focus remains on the upcoming public hearings. The real test for these 16 individuals will be how their professional histories translate to the bench when they are tasked with balancing the competing demands of public safety, due process, and the often-fragile dynamics of New York families.