Bert McMurtry remembers 1985, when a stabbing across the street and cars racing through the night made his new block feel like hell.
Today that same corner in Potter Highlands anchors a fight over the 1914 Colonial Revival church at 2601 W. 34th Ave., where a developer’s rezoning request has pitted neighbor against neighbor, neighbor against developer and neighbor against the city, Denver Gazette reported. The 36-block historic district, designated in 1979, sits a mile west of downtown. Its Victorian homes have escaped the scrape-and-build wave that pushed LoHi prices past $1 million, keeping bars and restaurants confined to the perimeter along West 32nd and West 38th avenues. In July, GMASH LLC bought the vacant Highland Christian Church — empty since the Hispanic congregation Iglesia Palabra de Vida left seven years ago — for $630,000. Last month Denver’s planning board approved rezoning the corner lot from U-TU-B residential to U-MX-2X, allowing commercial uses such as offices paired with food and beverage. Neighbors say they were not notified. The city’s Community Planning and Development office said it followed rules requiring notice within 200 feet. Planning board decisions rest on whether a request meets basic requirements. The church has no parking lot. Residents fear commercial traffic on narrow streets already lined with parked cars. They also worry rezoning leaves the historic property vulnerable to future uses more disruptive than what is proposed now. Lisa Bardwell, president of Highland United Neighbors Inc., who lives across Bryant Street, supports the rezone as the only way to save a deteriorating landmark. RealArchitecture Ltd., representing GMASH, called the building a “community gathering place” well suited for adaptive reuse, aiming to “preserve its historic character” through “low-intensity, neighborhood-serving mixed-use activities.”
At an open house, developer Kevin O’Brien and RealArchitecture’s Adam Berton showed a rendering of a restored sanctuary with stained-glass windows intact, children playing, a musician performing and a neighborhood bar. The concept includes possible tenant spaces such as a yoga studio and adds no indoor parking. O’Brien admitted the final use remains uncertain. “A lot of it depends on really on what direction we go,” he told Denver Gazette.
“Initially we wanted to do a duplex. That’s how we initially perceived it. Two construction experts, speaking on background, estimated a commercial or residential readaptation could exceed $3 million. One cautioned that historic repurposing requires neighbor cooperation and warned that even a low purchase price does not guarantee an investment will pay off. At a dining-room meeting last week, most neighbors asked for more time. Tim Boer, who chairs the land-use committee for HUNI, proposed restrictive covenants recorded to limit uses beyond what the city allows. “Businesses go under, and we’re setting ourselves up for a really contentious and character-altering situation for the neighborhood,” said Amy Van Ostall, who hosted the gathering. “We’re privatizing a public space, but I feel like the fact that it’s not going to be residential is driven by developer profit.”
Realtor Amy Berglund, a Potter Highlands homeowner, wrote that the developer bought under existing zoning. “If they believed they could come into this neighborhood they have no history with, change the zoning to the point of radically altering the character, all without any kind of real plan for this building, that is the height of naivety.” She noted the commercial designation still permits eventual liquor service, an outcome she called unthinkable. “People here want to walk to LoHi, not live in LoHi.”
Neighbors said the planning board advanced the measure despite letters urging denial. They met with an aide to Councilmember Amanda Sandoval but received no reassurance and sense she supports the project. O’Brien said he has suffered four break-ins at the vacant church and changed locks three times. Mary Broderick, a neighbor a block away, said residents must organize to gain a voice. “I feel that if we could pause the process for a little bit, we would have more time to dream what this neighborhood really wants for this church and what we’re willing to commit to,” she told the group. Neighbors are now in conversation with the developer.”