Documentary: Federal Judges Found ICE Wrongfully Detained Hundreds, Defied Orders

Federal judges in Minnesota found that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement wrongfully detained hundreds of immigrants during Operation Metro Surge, then violated court orders to release them, pushing the federal court system toward what Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey called a “terrifying question“: what happens when the government simply refuses to obey?

The findings come from “Thin I.C.E.,” a three-part documentary series by FOX 9 Documentaries that draws on dozens of interviews, hundreds of court records, and hours of body video footage from immigration operations in Chicago and Minneapolis. The final episode, titled “Chaos,” premieres Wednesday, Nov. 18 at 10:35 p.m. CT on FOX 9 and streaming platforms.

Patrick Schiltz, who served as chief judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota during the surge, described the caseload as unprecedented. “What happened in Minneapolis, in the Twin Cities, I should say, was pretty much unprecedented,” Schiltz said.

Julie Le, a former ICE attorney who gained attention for telling a judge “this job sucks,” said the agency failed to follow basic legal procedures. “It was pretty crazy because no one knows what’s going on,” Le said.

Documentary: Federal Judges Found ICE Wrongfully Detained Hundreds, Defied Orders
Photo: theminneapolis.org

Immigration attorneys described an agency that lost track of the people it had locked up. David Wilson said one client spent 45 days in detention before ICE realized he was there and eligible for a bond hearing. “Imagine being detained for 45 days, and they don’t even know you’re there,” Wilson said.

Garrison Gibson, who had checked in with ICE regularly for years, said agents cut off his ankle monitor after breaking into his home to detain him without a warrant. “They called my wife and asked where I was, because my ankle monitor was cut off,” Gibson said in the upcoming episode. “And my wife told them like, ‘how don’t y’all know, y’all just picked him up?'”

Detainees filed habeas corpus petitions arguing they were held without bond. Federal judges granted the majority during Operation Metro Surge and ordered ICE to release hundreds of people. The federal government, represented by U.S. Attorney Daniel Rosen and the Department of Homeland Security, defended the arrests and argued for mandatory detention despite decades of legal precedence.

But ICE then violated hundreds of those release orders, prompting threats of contempt proceedings and fears of a constitutional crisis. “What if the federal government refuses to abide by a court order?” Frey said. “That is a terrifying question.”

The legal situation changed when the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that ICE could hold many of those detainees indefinitely without bond while they awaited deportation. DHS argued the ruling validated its legal position. The dispute is likely headed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Even after the appellate decision, FOX 9 Investigators found ICE keeps losing in court because agents are arresting people without valid warrants.

“What if the federal government refuses to abide by a court order? That is a terrifying question.”

— Jacob Frey, Mayor of Minneapolis, in Thin I.C.E.

The first two episodes of “Thin I.C.E.,” titled “Worst of the Worst” and “Domestic Terrorists,” are available now on FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul, FOX LOCAL, and the FOX 9 YouTube channel.