The Miami Dolphins dropped a 24-22 decision to the Indianapolis Colts on Sunday, a narrow loss defined by a series of missed opportunities in the kicking game.
Despite a competitive performance from second-year quarterback Kyle McCord in his first NFL start, the Dolphins could not overcome three missed kicks and an extra point by kicker Zane Gonzalez at Lucas Oil Stadium.

The defeat drops Miami to 1-8 on the season, marking a third consecutive loss since their lone victory against the New York Jets on Oct. 25. While the scoreboard favored Indianapolis, the statistical reality of the game painted a different picture.
According to ESPN Research, the Colts became the first team in the Super Bowl era to win a game despite being outgained 293-276, losing the turnover margin 2-1, and committing 10 more penalties than the opponent (13 to three).

The primary friction point for the Dolphins was the special teams unit. Gonzalez missed a 47-yard attempt in the first quarter, failed on an extra point following a touchdown, and failed on a 51-yard go-ahead try in the fourth quarter. These misses left points on the board during a game decided by a two-point margin.
“We got to make the extra point. We have to make the field goal,” coach Jeff Hafley said. “I’m not going to ever BS you.”
That assessment came from Dolphins coach Jeff Hafley, who said that he opted to go for a fourth-and-2 from the Colts 8-yard line earlier in the game, a decision that resulted in a turnover on downs rather than an attempt at a short field goal.
McCord Manages Injury While Offense Finds Rhythm
Kyle McCord finished the afternoon 17 of 32 for 209 yards, adding a rushing touchdown and a fumble that resulted in an Indianapolis defensive score. McCord played through a hand injury sustained after hitting it against Colts edge rusher Laiatu Latu early in the game, maintaining composure against a complex defensive front.
The offense found a spark in the second half through creative play-calling. Offensive coordinator and play caller Bobby Slowik utilized a trick play that saw wide receiver Malik Washington throw a 34-yard touchdown pass to Jalen Tolbert.
Washington, who also recorded 50 receiving yards, noted the chemistry building between the young teammates. “We’ll continue to grow. We’ll continue to work together,” Washington said. “For his first one, we’re just going to continue to build on it.”
Despite the offensive flashes, the Dolphins struggled to contain the Colts’ rushing attack in their first game without Zach Sieler, who is currently out for the season with a torn biceps. Indianapolis running back Jonathan Taylor rushed for 83 yards, while Seth McGowan added 77 yards and a touchdown.
Linebacker Jordyn Brooks, who led the Dolphins with nine tackles, was blunt about the defensive performance: “We didn’t stop the run at all. Overall, it wasn’t what the standard is.”
Defense Forces Turnovers to Keep Game Close
The Dolphins’ defense did manage to force turnovers, keeping the game within reach. Rookie cornerback Chris Johnson returned a Daniel Jones interception 59 yards for a touchdown in the third quarter—his second consecutive week with an interception. Safety Michael Taaffe recorded an interception on fourth down during the second quarter, while both Brooks and defensive end Chop Robinson forced fumbles.
Beyond the immediate frustration of the loss, the result carries long-term implications for the franchise’s draft capital. Because the Dolphins currently hold a better draft position than the two picks belonging to the New York Jets—who own Indianapolis’ first-round selection—the outcome helps Miami’s standing in the upcoming draft order.
As the team looks to rebuild, these developmental weeks for players like McCord and Johnson remain the primary focus.
The Dolphins will look to correct their special teams and defensive lapses next Sunday when they travel to face the Buffalo Bills, who currently sit at 8-1. “Obviously, it stings to come up 10 yards short, 15 yards short, but that’s life in the NFL,” McCord said after the game.