Douglas Jose Centeno-Vargas Arraigned in Bridgeport on Murder Charges After Extradition from Nicaragua

“If I can’t have her, nobody will have her,” Detective Jeffrey Holtz said Wednesday, describing the motive that drove Douglas Jose Centeno-Vargas to allegedly execute Evelyn Rayo-Mairena and flee to a country with no extradition treaty.

The 31-year-old Nicaraguan national was arraigned in Bridgeport Superior Court on murder, risk of injury to a minor, and tampering with evidence charges, held on $4 million bond after a transnational manhunt that spanned months and three countries.

Rayo-Mairena, 24, was found shot in the head on Black Rock Avenue around 9:30 p.m. on Oct. 21, 2025, several yards from the porch where her 1-year-old daughter sat uninjured in a car seat, wrapped in a bloodied blanket. She died at St. Vincent’s Hospital. Her daughter, now 2, lives with her father.

Police allege Centeno-Vargas shot Rayo-Mairena inside his car, dragged her onto the pavement, left the baby on the porch, and was driven to JFK Airport by an unidentified person. He flew to El Salvador, then Nicaragua, his and Rayo-Mairena’s native country, where they were from the same town and knew each other as friends.

“What we believe is sometimes friends have a relationship and one person in the relationship wants more than the other person does,” Holtz said at the Wednesday news conference. “And we believe this was ‘if I can’t have her, nobody will have her.'”

Nicaragua and the United States have no extradition treaty. That fact alone made Centeno-Vargas’s return “extremely rare and remarkable,” in Holtz’s words, a result he said investigators were told would probably never happen. The breakthrough came after Rayo-Mairena’s family pressured Nicaraguan authorities directly. “The extradition was due in large part to Rayo-Mairena’s family putting pressure on the Nicaraguan authorities,” Holtz said.

People.com reported a critical detail absent from other accounts: Nicaragua initially offered to try Centeno-Vargas domestically for murder, an offer the State’s Attorney rejected. Only after that refusal did the Nicaraguan government relent and allow U.S. Marshals and Interpol agents to repatriate him. He was flown to Texas several weeks ago, held at Montgomery County Jail outside Houston, and transported to Bridgeport by detectives Tuesday night.

Bridgeport Police Chief Roderick Porter called it a “very delicate and complex investigation” and a “very sad situation.” Holtz was blunter about the toll on his detectives: “When we found that as investigators, that he fled, our hearts dropped.”

The department credited the outcome to coordination among its Homicide and Major Crimes detectives, the Fugitive Unit, the U.S. Marshals Service, Interpol, and the U.S. Departments of State and Justice.

“I’m very thankful at the work that everybody here did,” Rayo-Mairena’s sister, Maria Carolina Rayo, said through an officer translating at the news conference, holding a photo of her sister. “I’m here representing my sister to say thank you to everybody.”

She added a message to other perpetrators: “Justice does exist so don’t think that you can do what you did and then take off and think you’re gonna hide and whatever, but you will get caught. My sister didn’t deserve that.”

The driver who took Centeno-Vargas to JFK remains unidentified and the investigation into that assistance continues. Centeno-Vargas is expected to return to court next month.