Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy refused Thursday to confirm that Democrat Mary Peltola will take her U.S. Senate seat in January, telling Newsmax that state and federal investigations are meant to aid a potential challenge by the losing Republican candidate, Sen. Dan Sullivan.
Dunleavy acknowledged “enough smoke to indicate that there may be a fire” in probes targeting a third candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., and declined to push back when host Rob Finnerty suggested Alaska’s elections are rigged. “Correct. Correct,” the governor replied. Democracy Docket reported the interview and the governor’s subsequent refusal to commit to signing Peltola’s certificate of election.
Peltola won the November election with more than 50 percent of the vote, a threshold that makes a spoiler candidate mathematically irrelevant to the outcome. Both the Alaska Department of Law and the U.S. Department of Justice are investigating whether Peltola’s campaign helped recruit the younger Sullivan as a spoiler — a practice known as “ballot-stacking” that is not uncommon or illegal.
Fox News reported Wednesday that the DOJ has issued more than 200 subpoenas across multiple states, citing an unnamed law enforcement source who said the probe includes multiple criminal targets.
“The gap in the votes becomes problematic going forward,” Dunleavy conceded on air. “If you trust that vote count, I suppose,” Finnerty added. The governor did not challenge the premise.
Alaska officials are expected to certify Peltola’s win by Nov. 25. Sen. Sullivan then has until Dec. 5 to file a formal contest. “The question is, on the Dec. 5 date, if there is an action filed to contest the election, where we’re at that point with our investigations — to see if that information would assist with any contested action by the senator himself,” Dunleavy said. “We don’t know yet.”
Asked directly whether Peltola would be seated in January, Dunleavy equivocated. “I don’t have the answer to that question — seriously,” he said. “We’re investigating. All I can tell you is, we’ll see where that leads. It’s going to take a little bit of time.”
The governor is required by law to sign the certificate of election. When Democracy Docket asked his office Thursday to confirm he would do so, a spokesperson sidestepped the question: “Under Alaska law, it is the lieutenant governor — not the governor — who controls and supervises the Division of Elections. The director of elections certifies candidate election results.”
Dunleavy leaves office Dec. 7.
Separately on Thursday, the DOJ admitted in court that its own lawsuit seeking to block certification over the Dan Sullivans issue — filed on former President Donald Trump’s orders — is now moot. Trump has claimed Democrats committed “fraud,” and some Republican members of Congress have suggested the Senate could try to block Peltola from being seated.
Dunleavy, a former Pennsylvania schoolteacher who moved to Alaska in 1983 and spent nearly two decades as an educator in northwest Arctic villages, was first elected governor in 2018 after defeating former U.S. Sen. Mark Begich. He won a second term in 2022, becoming the first incumbent Republican governor of Alaska to win reelection since Jay Hammond in 1978.
The Elias Law Group represents the Peltola campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee. Firm Chair Marc Elias is the founder of Democracy Docket.
Worth a look