ESPN’s Jordan Reid has the Atlanta Falcons selecting Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr with the No. 8 overall pick in his latest mock draft, a projection that effectively writes off Michael Penix Jr. after just 10 weeks of the 2026 season, Atlanta Falcons On SI reported.
The Falcons sit 3-7 heading into a brutal stretch against Minnesota and Detroit, and the No. 8 slot — a draft position made familiar during the Arthur Smith era — could climb higher if Atlanta slides toward 3-9.
Reid’s rationale for Carr reads like a direct rebuttal of the Penix experiment: an instinctive, polished passer granted significant autonomy in Notre Dame’s offense, described by Reid as a more mobile Kirk Cousins, or as others have framed it, a more toolsy Brock Purdy.
“Carr is an instinctive passer who consistently has answers and has already been given considerable autonomy in Notre Dame’s offense. He doesn’t have the high-end traits of some passers in the class (picture a more mobile Kirk Cousins), but he is polished in many of the skills that are essential to playing the position.”
Reid wrote on ESPN.

The irony is thick. Atlanta used the No. 8 pick on Penix in 2024, drafting him behind a veteran Kirk Cousins in a move that baffled the league at the time. Now, a new regime under general manager Ian Cunningham — hired in January with a barren draft cupboard and cap straitjacket — faces the prospect of spending another top-10 selection on the same position.
Cunningham will have ample picks and cap space this offseason, but he also inherits a roster headed for a ninth consecutive losing season with holes at offensive tackle, wide receiver, and cornerback.
Reid’s board has quarterbacks flying off the board early. Drew Mestemaker goes No. 2 to the Jets via a trade with the Chargers. The Dolphins (No. 3), Eagles (No. 5), and Cardinals (No. 7) are all flagged as quarterback threats, while the Chargers at No. 4 could trade down to a team leapfrogging Atlanta.
If the Falcons stay put and pass on a quarterback, Indiana’s Charlie Becker (WR, No. 4 to Chargers), Notre Dame’s Leonard Moore (CB, No. 6 to Jets), and LSU’s Jordan Seaton (OT, No. 7 to Cardinals) are the premium non-quarterback options coming off the board. Utah tackle Zereoue Williams goes No. 9 to Houston.
Carr’s 2026 tape backs up the hype. Through 10 games, he has completed 67.9% of his passes for 2,385 yards with 23 touchdowns against just two interceptions, steering Notre Dame to a 9-1 record, according to Heavy.

“He wants to be the best, and he’s obsessed with improvement. He’s very competitive, and I don’t think the outside expectations weigh on him. It’s his leadership. The quarterback is a natural leadership position. If you’re the starting quarterback of Notre Dame, people expect you to lead, and he’s doing a really good job of that this year, not just leading the offense, but being a vocal leader for the team.”
Notre Dame head coach Marcus Freeman said earlier this year via Roundtable Sports.
He enrolled at Notre Dame in 2023, redshirted as the fourth-string quarterback behind Riley Leonard in 2024, and won the starting job in 2025 after Leonard entered the NFL and backup Steve Angeli transferred. Carr is a philosophy major in the College of Arts and Letters.
Inside the building, the public stance remains unchanged. Former Falcons quarterback Matt Ryan told CBS Sports ahead of the Kansas City game that he believes in Penix, citing his preparation, command of the game plan, and ability to put teammates in position to succeed.
The organization is “100% behind Penix,” Heavy said, emphasizing his return from knee surgery that cost him the first two games. But three years is a lifetime in the NFL, and the clock on the 2024 first-rounder is ticking louder with every loss.