A San Antonio Express-News column argues that the relentless national commentary on Texas quarterback Arch Manning has become a civic obligation completely disconnected from his actual on-field performance.
The piece, published Saturday, frames the phenomenon as a uniquely American requirement: every citizen must issue at least one loud Manning opinion per week, regardless of whether they follow college football or possess any relevant expertise.
CNBC Host Asks Mullin About Manning Playing Time
The column cites a Tuesday interview on CNBC where host Joe Kernen asked Markwayne Mullin to evaluate Manning’s playing time.
“You think Arch Manning should start doing some of this stuff earlier?” Kernen asked, pivoting from aviation chaos to the Longhorns’ depth chart.
A Manufactured Frenzy
Manning, did not request the hype. He has spent four years at Texas attempting to be intentionally boring in interviews, save for one incident where he laughed at a tasteless video in front of reporters, igniting a multi-day news cycle.
The column draws a sharp contrast with Johnny Manziel, the last Texas quarterback to captivate the internet. Manziel earned attention through compelling play, celebrations, and off-field drama. Manning, by comparison, offers none of that.
He throws an NFL-caliber deep ball occasionally and makes baffling decisions at times — a profile the column describes as “talented guy who looks like a first-rounder at times but battles inconsistency,” common to two or three dozen programs.
Manning Faces Extreme Scrutiny for Every Play
Every Manning mistake is scrutinized to death, even when he is running for his life behind an overmatched offensive line. Every success — such as hitting a running back in stride on a game-winning swing pass at LSU on Nov. 14 — transforms him into the second coming of Vince Young.
The latest cycle erupted when Manning confirmed he would participate in senior day festivities at Royal-Memorial Stadium this Saturday despite retaining a year of eligibility. The gesture settles nothing: he could still turn pro, return for a fifth year, or transfer elsewhere.
The Verdict Is Pending
In the meantime, the column concludes, the court of public opinion remains in session. “In the case of the People vs. Arch, we await an official ruling from the U.S. Supreme Court,” the piece reads.