Just after midnight on Nov. 7, viewers on Facebook watched a Ramsey County deputy chase a red SUV through a St. Paul neighborhood at more than 100 miles per hour before it slammed into a tree, killing two men in their 20s.
The crash, streamed live on the sheriff office’s “Live on Patrol” page, has reignited a debate over pursuit policies that differ sharply between the Ramsey County Sheriff’s Office and the police departments in Minneapolis and St. Paul, the Star Tribune reported. It also forced a public reckoning with the ethics of broadcasting fatal collisions in real time.
Deputy Nicole Sparks attempted to stop the SUV for failing to come to a complete halt at a stop sign and for lacking a front license plate, Sheriff Bob Fletcher said. The suspected driver, Kendell Lewis, 27, was pronounced dead at the scene; passenger Robert Reid, 28, died later at the hospital.
Lewis had outstanding warrants for drug possession, trafficking and fleeing police, though Sparks did not know that when the pursuit began, Fletcher said. She reached 85 mph during a chase that lasted roughly 50 seconds and covered about a mile.
“If you have a ‘flee at all costs’ mentality, it might cost you your life,” Fletcher said, defending the decision to pursue. He said the chase was “completely within our policy” and noted his office does not restrict pursuits based on the severity of the initial infraction, unlike some other departments.

“When you begin a pursuit, there’s really only a few things that can happen, and almost all of them are bad. So there has to be a pretty high need to apprehend to justify putting everyone at that risk.”
Dennis Kenney, professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice
Dennis Kenney, a professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice who has researched police chases, called it a “questionable pursuit” based on the dash-camera footage and the minor nature of the initial violations.
Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum (PERF), said many major city departments — including those in New York, Chicago and Houston — have tightened policies in recent years to restrict chases to violent felonies where a suspect poses an imminent threat.
A 2023 PERF report compiled for the Department of Justice recommends that standard, stating: “You can get a suspect another day, but you can’t get a life back.”
Ramsey County’s policy allows a pursuit “when the need for immediate apprehension or the risk to public safety outweighs the risk created as a result of the pursuit.” It lists ten factors deputies must weigh, including the severity of the offense and whether the offender can be caught more safely later.
By contrast, St. Paul and Minneapolis policies generally prohibit chases for minor traffic offenses, permitting them primarily for violent felonies or when a driver’s behavior before the stop creates an imminent, life-threatening danger.
Rebecca Noecker, the St. Paul City Council president who was just elected to the Ramsey County Board, said she would “strongly support” an investigation into the sheriff’s pursuit policies to bring them into closer alignment with St. Paul’s stricter rules.
“A fatal pursuit is not the same thing as being held accountable in a court of law, and it’s just not how we should be doing law enforcement in the country,” she said. Noecker also warned that differing policies among agencies operating in the same jurisdiction breed public mistrust.
Fletcher countered that the pendulum is swinging back toward pro-pursuit policies, arguing that chases for lower-level offenses often uncover suspects with warrants or guns. He also claimed more suspects are fleeing because they know some departments will not chase. “If you don’t chase, the criminals are going to commit more crimes,” he said.
The livestream added another layer of controversy. The video remained on the “Live on Patrol” Facebook page for hours, showing Lewis lying on the sidewalk and Reid stumbling before falling and being handcuffed, before it was removed “out of sensitivity for the families,” Fletcher said. By then, it had been copied and reposted widely.
Jane Kirtley, a retired professor of media ethics at the University of Minnesota, said law enforcement faces different transparency standards than news outlets, but acknowledged the images “may be very important for public oversight, even if they are offensive or gruesome.” She said she appreciates Fletcher’s “stated desire to be transparent and accountable,” noting that other departments often cite privacy to withhold footage.
Noecker drew a sharper line: “I think there’s a big difference between police accountability that we have with our body-worn cameras, with our in-car cameras … that do help improve transparency, and the kind of ‘law enforcement as entertainment’ that I think this kind of livestreaming has turned into.”
Dennis Kenney, a professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, has spent more than 35 years in criminal justice. He worked as a Florida police officer, a director of research and planning in Savannah, Georgia, and a project director for the Police Foundation.
He also served as an associate director and director of research for the Police Executive Research Forum (PERF). Kenney is the author or co-author of numerous books and articles, including Police Pursuits: What We Know (2000). He holds a Ph.D. in criminal justice from Rutgers University, earned in 1986.
Fletcher said the program, launched in 2020 and modeled on shows like “Live PD,” aims to show the public what deputies do — “a lot of boredom on the street” and the sudden moments when “death is around the corner.”