Federal Jury Convicts Jonathan Rinderknecht in Palisades Wildfire Arson Case

“Everything kind of started to point towards one conclusion,” Cameron, a 30-year-old college student and juror, told reporters after the verdict Friday.

A federal jury in Los Angeles convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht, 30, of two arson charges for igniting the Lachman fire on Jan. 1, 2025, a blaze prosecutors said smoldered underground for six days before erupting as the Palisades fire that killed 12 people and destroyed 6,500 structures.

The verdict, delivered after two days of deliberation, caps a rare federal retrial after a June jury deadlocked 10 to 2 in favor of acquittal, Los Angeles Times reported.

Prosecutors narrowed the indictment for the second trial, dropping a third charge and limiting the first count to damage from the initial Lachman fire while the second count still sought to hold Rinderknecht responsible for the full scope of the Palisades inferno. First Assistant U.S. Atty. Bill Essayli said the revision was designed to persuade jurors torn over linking Rinderknecht to the catastrophic reignition.

The prosecution’s arc

Assistant U.S. Atty. Mark Williams told jurors Rinderknecht was “mad at everything and frustrated” when he hiked to a clearing overlooking Pacific Palisades on New Year’s Eve 2024 and used a lighter to start the fire, CNN reported. Digital forensics placed his car at the trailhead and cell tower data tracked his movement on the hill.

Fire camera images narrowed the ignition window, and experts eliminated fireworks — the defense’s alternate theory — as a cause. Prosecutors also played a screen-recorded video Rinderknecht made while calling 911 more than a dozen times as he walked down the hill; in it, he asked ChatGPT, “Are you at fault if a fire is lit because of your cigarettes?” — evidence, Williams said, of a manufactured alibi.

“This fire was an incendiary fire started by an open flame,” Williams said in closing. “The defendant is the only one who could have started it.”

The defense’s counter

Defense attorney Steve Haney argued no one saw his client ignite the blaze and that the origin point was accessible to the public for six days before the Palisades fire erupted. “Six days of anyone and everyone walking across the spot the government now calls a crime scene,” Haney said, per CNN.

He presented a retired U.S. Forest Service investigator who disputed the government’s origin determination and highlighted a neighbor’s account of teenagers fleeing the trailhead. Haney also attacked the investigation’s sequence: lab tests to confirm a lighter could have started the fire were requested 11 months after Rinderknecht was charged. “The decision came first, the test came 11 months later,” Haney said. “Decided, charged and tested. That’s backwards.”

Haney told jurors to disregard Rinderknecht’s angry texts and erratic behavior as “evidence of the man, not evidence of the act.” After the verdict, he said the team would appeal. “We are disappointed in the verdict, but respect the jury process,” Haney said. “After a lengthy deliberation, they clearly gave this case a great deal of consideration.”

Federal Jury Convicts Jonathan Rinderknecht in Palisades Wildfire Arson Case
Photo: cnn.com

Juror dynamics and the holdout

Cameron, the sole juror who initially voted not guilty, said the panel took multiple votes and “just kept going on and on and on and just asked every question, are we going to be right about this because it’s a person’s life.”

He ultimately concluded Rinderknecht “had to have been the one on that hill, he had to have been the one to start the fire.” Cameron stopped short of saying Rinderknecht intended to burn down the Palisades, telling The Guardian he believed the intent was only to start a fire.

Civil liability untouched

The verdict does not resolve the wave of civil lawsuits against the city and Los Angeles Fire Department over their response to the Lachman fire. Firefighters have testified in those cases about communication failures and a decision to leave the area prematurely.

Alex Robertson, an attorney for fire victims in a consolidated suit, told The Guardian the cause is legally beside the point: “For the purpose of our civil case, the fire could have been started by lightning and would have had the same result. It doesn’t matter what started the fire. It’s what happened — what didn’t happen in terms of protecting the residents of the Palisades and Malibu after the fire started.”