King Loses Bid To Vacate Sentence In Pennsylvania Superior Court

King lost his bid to vacate his sentence this week in the Pennsylvania Superior Court.

The 50-year-old Johnstown man, David M. King, faces a sentence of 55 to 110 years for 54 counts of sexual abuse of a minor that spanned a decade. This ruling confirms the initial sentencing by Cambria County Judge David Tulowitski more than nine years ago after a jury found him guilty.

This case hinges on the strict procedural timelines of Pennsylvania’s Post Conviction Hearing Act, or PCRA. King argued his petition was based on fraud committed by his counsel and the prosecution regarding a lack of formal arraignment, but the Superior Court panel rejected this contention.

“Simply stating that the motion (to vacate) is not a PCRA petition does not make it so.”

The crucial element here is timing; King’s case became final in January 2019 when the window for seeking review by the United States Supreme Court closed. His petition arrived in late October 2025, making it “facially untimely” under the PCRA statute, which has a one-year limit from the case becoming final.

The opposing view rests on the PCRA’s scope for constitutional violations or ineffective counsel, a due process challenge the court acknowledged as “unquestionably cognizable by the PCRA.”

Pennsylvania state court rules confirm the framework the Superior Court used to evaluate King’s claim.

“defects in the arraignment do not constitute reversible error unless they prejudice the defendant’s rights.”

stated the Superior Court opinion. The counter-argument King put forward suggested a broader statute allowed intervention if there was a “showing of fraud or other circumstance so grave or compelling as to constitute extraordinary causes justifying intervention by the court,” yet the panel ultimately sided with the prosecution’s interpretation of the statute.

Pa superior court judges

The official documentation from the Superior Court panel rejects the notion that the petition bypassed the PCRA statute, confirming the one-year time bar applies, unless exceptions like governmental interference or newly discovered facts apply—none of which the panel found in King’s case.

David M. King resides in the State Correctional Institution Houtzdale.