Federal Permitting Bill Splits South Dakota Republicans, 37 GOP Lawmakers Align With Democrats

A federal permitting bill designed to speed energy projects has done something rare in South Dakota: it scrambled the state’s Republican delegation, pushing two U.S. senators into opposite corners and driving 37 Republican state lawmakers into alignment with Democrats.

Fifty legislators and lawmakers-elect — 37 Republicans, 12 Democrats and one independent — signed a letter Monday urging Sens. John Thune and Mike Rounds to oppose the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, South Dakota Searchlight reported. The legislation would streamline federal reviews for power plants, transmission lines and pipelines while requiring data centers to cover their own grid-connection costs.

“This bill is an incremental erosion of our fundamental rights,” Sen. Joy Hohn, R-Hartford, told South Dakota Searchlight. Hohn, who won reelection this month, has fought a proposed carbon-capture pipeline across eastern South Dakota. She drafted the letter with Sen. Red Dawn Foster, D-Pine Ridge, a member of the Oglala Sioux Tribe who is term-limited this year.

Federal Permitting Bill Splits South Dakota Republicans, 37 GOP Lawmakers Align With Democrats
Photo: yahoo.com

The measure passed a procedural Senate vote 73-25 earlier this month. Thune voted to advance it; Rounds was the lone Republican to vote no. Thune argues the overhaul will lower energy costs and prevent projects from languishing in bureaucracy for years. “Delays cause project budgets to balloon, which then leads to higher costs for American consumers,” he said during a Senate floor speech Tuesday.

But the coalition back home sees a different ledger. The letter warns that economic development “must not come at the expense of environmental protections, agricultural interests, private property rights, tribal sovereignty, local control, or the health and well-being of our communities.”

South Dakota Public Utilities Commission Chair Chris Nelson, a Republican, said the commission is “adamantly opposed” to provisions letting transmission developers bypass state regulators. “What it really does is it takes away the South Dakota PUC’s ability to evaluate projects fairly under our statute and to work with landowners here, to work out their concerns, and make a final decision here,” Nelson told South Dakota Searchlight.

Eminent domain remains a raw nerve. The Legislature and Gov. Larry Rhoden banned its use for carbon pipelines last year. Thune’s office says the federal bill would not override that ban, but Nelson questioned whether federal eminent-domain authority would still apply and whether federal regulators would be required to weigh landowner objections.

“You can accomplish that without having to have very drastic, negative impacts on environmental law, the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Water Act, all the way to the utter disregard of tribal sovereignty, local control and even, frankly, the state Public Utilities Commission.”

Sen. Erik Muckey, D-Sioux Falls, Senate Minority Leader-elect

Rep. Eric Emery, D-Rosebud, the House Minority Leader-elect, said the bill narrows what states and tribes can review under the Clean Water Act and allows only 150 days to challenge a federal permit in court — too short, he said.

“As a Native legislator from Rosebud, I can’t get past what this bill does to tribes,” Emery told South Dakota Searchlight. “Consultation on sacred sites and cultural resources is part of what the United States owes tribal nations under the treaties. It shouldn’t be optional.”

The Great Plains Tribal Chairmen’s Association opposes the legislation. Emery added, “This is one issue where I agree with a lot of my Republican colleagues here at home. Local control and tribal sovereignty don’t belong to one party in South Dakota.”

Not every Republican sees it that way. Sen. Casey Crabtree, R-Madison, the incoming Senate majority leader, supports the bill and said lawmakers should commend Thune for working across the aisle to “deliver affordable electricity, fix our roads and bridges, upgrade our telecommunications systems and maintain strong protections for South Dakotans.” No member of the incoming Republican legislative leadership teams in either chamber signed the letter.

“The American people are united behind the issue of affordability,” Crabtree said.

U.S. Rep. Dusty Johnson, R-S.D., called the bill “the most important affordability bill in decades” on social media last week. “If we want lower taxes, lower energy bills, better roads and bridges, we have to right-size our regulatory approach,” Johnson said, adding it protects property rights and forces data centers to pay their fair share.

The letter falls short of a formal legislative resolution. Only 20 signers are House members who will serve in January, short of the 36 needed for a majority; 12 are incoming senators, short of the 18 required. Lawmakers don’t convene until January, so the letter was the only immediate vehicle to reach Washington.

The bill awaits a final Senate vote. Rounds said after the procedural vote he hoped to work with colleagues to address the concerns raised by Nelson and the lawmakers.