"We already have strong ties there. We know where to work and how everything is organized," Dr. Yael Richler-Friedman told The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com.
Fifteen years after the State Comptroller criticized Israel’s Education Ministry for concentrating Holocaust education trips in Poland, the country remains the program’s near-exclusive destination.
The ministry acknowledged in a 2009 Knesset committee meeting that trips solely to Poland risked a distorted historical understanding, yet the 2011 comptroller report also flagged high costs, unequal access, and a lack of outcome assessment. The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com reported that diplomatic crises, a delegation suspension, and disputes over historical narrative have not produced a full alternative.
Infrastructure and guide training lock in Poland
Poland’s concentration of sites — Warsaw, Krakow, Auschwitz-Birkenau, Treblinka, Majdanek, cemeteries, and mass-shooting locations — allows students to study pre-war Jewish life alongside the machinery of murder, Richler-Friedman said. Germany offers the rise of Nazism; Lithuania and Ukraine illuminate mass shootings and local collaboration. You need retraining. It’s very, very complicated," she told The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com.

So, we rely on what we already know how to do best," Richler-Friedman said.
2023 deal resumed trips with site requirements
Israel suspended trips in 2022 over security arrangements and content disagreements, including Polish legislation on historical responsibility and property claims. A March 2023 deal resumed travel, requiring delegations to visit at least one site from a Polish-proposed list. Yad Vashem objected that some listed institutions could present an inaccurate account. The Education Ministry rejected claims the agreement mandated visits to sites that distort history.

Costs excluded poorer students; demographics unknown
The program grew from about 200 students in 1988 to roughly 25,000 annually by 2009. In 2009, parents covered NIS 147 million of the NIS 162 million total — 91%. Two-thirds of delegations came from the most affluent third of schools. A 2012 study found 61% of non-participants cited cost. The ministry later allocated over NIS 50 million for low-income subsidies, but current participation demographics and parental cost shares are unknown.
A 2007 RAMA study published in 2011 reported 87% of participants felt a stronger connection to Jewish history, 92% better understood Israel’s significance, and 85% felt proud to be Israeli. The Knesset Research and Information Center said in 2023 that no new effectiveness study had been conducted since 2011.
Students detained for gestures; ministry silent on reforms
In March 2025, a student was detained at Auschwitz for a gesture interpreted as a Nazi salute; a classmate said he was waving. In 2018, two students were sent home after indecent exposure at Majdanek. "We do not take this lightly," Richler-Friedman said. The Education Ministry did not respond to The Jerusalem Post | The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com’s questions on implementing comptroller recommendations, new studies, or why Poland remains the sole destination.