A federal judge handed Isaiah Adams six months in prison Wednesday, a sentence that lands far heavier than the probation his lawyer requested but lighter than the years prosecutors could have sought for a scheme that fixed college games for profit.
Adams, 24, once celebrated as Florida’s Mr. Basketball and a star at Jacksonville’s Paxon School for Advanced Studies, pleaded guilty in March to bribery in a sporting contest and aiding and abetting.
United States District Judge Nitza I. Quiñones Alejandro imposed the prison term, 15 months of supervised release, and a $17,500 forfeiture order in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, WJXT reported. Another defendant, Dyquavion Short, received one day in prison, two years of supervised release, and a $15,000 forfeiture the same day.
The case pulls back the curtain on a sprawling operation that moved into NCAA Division I basketball in 2024. Prosecutors said Adams and two University at Buffalo teammates — Shawn Fulcher and an unnamed third player — agreed to manipulate three Bulls games in February and March 2024, intentionally underperforming so Buffalo would fail to cover the first-half point spread, the Florida Times-Union reported.
The Buffalo TV station reported that Todd Fiore, Adams’ attorney, argued in a sentencing memorandum that his client had never been in “any sort of trouble” and played a relatively minor role in the scheme, a characterization prosecutors disputed.

Fiore detailed a childhood marked by poverty and violence in Jacksonville. After Adams’ father stopped paying child support, Adams, his mother, and his sister spent 16 months in a transitional shelter when he was 7 years old. Basketball was his escape, Fiore told WIVB in Buffalo.
The three games in question
Authorities identified three specific contests where the fix was attempted:
- Feb. 24, 2024 vs. Western Michigan: Buffalo trailed by 15 at halftime, failing to cover the 3-point first-half spread. The gamblers’ bet hit.
- Feb. 27, 2024 vs. Kent State: Buffalo went scoreless for the final 4:40 of the half, and the implicated players committed several turnovers. Yet Kent State led by only 8 at the break, failing to cover the 8.5-point spread. The plot failed.
- March 5, 2024 vs. Ohio: Buffalo trailed by 7 at halftime, failing to cover the 5.5-point first-half spread. The gamblers’ bet hit again.
In each case, the fixers wagered that Buffalo would not cover the first-half number. Two of three attempts succeeded, according to the indictment detailed by the Times-Union.
A journey from Paxon to prison
Adams led Paxon to consecutive state final fours in 2019 and 2020, averaging 23.7 points and 11.1 rebounds as a senior. He was only the second player from Jacksonville city limits to win Florida’s Mr. Basketball, following James Collins of Jackson in 1993. He signed with UCF, transferred to Buffalo for two seasons, and finished his college eligibility at Toledo. Last season, he played professionally in Cyprus for Apollon Limassol.
Two other Jacksonville-area players — Mo Arnold, who started 38 games at Jacksonville University from 2019 to 2021, and Oumar Koureissi, who appeared in 12 games off the bench for JU in 2022-23 — were also charged in the broader indictment. Neither has been sentenced yet.
The University at Buffalo, founded in 1846 as a private medical college by a group that included future U.S. President Millard Fillmore, merged with the State University of New York system in 1962.
Today it is one of two SUNY flagship institutions and the largest public university in New York, enrolling nearly 32,000 students across 13 schools and colleges as of fall 2026. Its athletic teams, the Bulls, compete in NCAA Division I as members of the Mid-American Conference.
The sentencing marks a stunning fall for a player once synonymous with Jacksonville basketball excellence. The scheme, prosecutors said, involved five “fixers,” including former NBA guard Antonio Blakeney, and implicated athletes from more than a dozen college programs nationwide.