Four Timberline Football Players Sue Boise District Over Suspensions

Four varsity football players at Timberline High School in Boise filed a federal lawsuit this week accusing the Boise School District of suspending them under public pressure rather than evidence, the Idaho Press reported.

The suit, filed by four students identified as John Does, three of whom are 18, alleges the district violated their due-process and First Amendment rights after screenshots from a Snapchat group chat titled “Gameday lunch” circulated online in early October.

The messages included a threat to “hang her from a ligh[t] post and let the birds pick at her brain for days” and a reference to the gang-rape allegations at Cornell University: “U think Cornell was bad just wait for us,” according to the Anchorage Daily News.

Boise Police opened a criminal investigation that remains active. “BPD has reviewed the evidence currently available and will continue to evaluate additional evidence as it is received from the social media platforms,” spokesperson Haley Williams wrote in an email to the Idaho Press, adding that receiving and evaluating that evidence and interviewing additional witnesses “is anticipated that it will take time.”

Four Timberline Students Sue Boise School District Over Snapchat Discipline — Idaho News 6

District officials suspended the players for 17 days in October, canceled the homecoming football game, and ultimately ordered three of the four to attend online school for the remainder of the semester after a disciplinary panel hearing. The fourth accepted in-home tutoring and agreed not to return before his hearing, court documents show.

The lawsuit contends the panel was stacked. Principal Chad Wright recommended removal as an additional punishment, the complaint says, and the panel members were district employees whose supervisors “had publicly expressed condemnation” of the boys and “promised the public that (the) plaintiffs would be punished.” The district’s handbook allows long-term suspension or expulsion for “verbal, written or physical abuse (e.g. hazing, fighting, threats, bullying).”

Timberline Walkout
Photo: idahopress.com

“The teammates believed these actions were negatively contributing to (their teammate’s) mental state and were concerned for him,” the lawsuit says, alleging the targeted female student — referred to as Jane Moe — had harassed a football player she dated on and off for months.

The complaint says she told him to kill himself, vandalized his property, propositioned his teammates, and once left a voicemail pretending to be a healthcare representative telling his mother he needed STD testing. Neither the football player nor the female student has faced discipline, the suit claims.

Parents and students pushed back hard. More than 14,000 people signed a Change.org petition demanding accountability, and students staged a walkout that spread to another school. “This incident is not just about a single event but highlights a pattern of behavior that needs immediate attention and resolution,” Timberline student Ellie Hall wrote in the petition.

Jennifer Graham, a parent of a Timberline student, told the Anchorage Daily News she had “little faith that the school administration would fully address the incident” given how she perceived past bullying complaints were handled. “It’s just going to fade away, and nothing will be done,” she said.

Dan Hollar, public affairs administrator for the Boise School District, told the Anchorage Daily News the reported threats are “serious, and we have treated them that way.” He added, “We understand why families are concerned, and we are concerned whenever a family feels a report of bullying was not adequately addressed.”

The district launched a Title IX investigation and threat assessment alongside the police inquiry. The board of trustees said in an open letter that the process “although not as quickly or as ruthlessly as some on social media would like, is working.”

The Boise School District, founded in 1865 under Idaho Territory, is the state’s second-oldest school system. It once held the title of Idaho’s largest district, peaking at 27,070 students in 1997, before being surpassed by the adjacent West Ada School District. The district operates four traditional senior high schools, including Timberline High School, which opened in 1998, and serves a 456-square-mile area across Ada County.

The students are asking a jury to order their return to Timberline, expunge their disciplinary records, and award compensatory damages. The district did not immediately respond to a request for comment from The Washington Post.

Members of the Cornell University community march to Day Hall on Monday as part of the Justice for Survivors protest
Photo: adn.com