“Everybody knows him and respects him,” said Ramsey County Undersheriff Mike Martin, a retired Minneapolis police commander, after a meeting of metro law enforcement executives at the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension headquarters in St. Paul on Monday.
Mayor Jacob Frey vetoed the City Council’s 8-5 rejection of interim Chief Bill Peterson’s nomination Thursday, keeping the 31-year department veteran in the running for the permanent role.
The veto sets up a prolonged standoff at City Hall. If the council cannot muster a supermajority to override, Peterson’s nomination enters what City Clerk Casey Carl described as a “gray area” — stuck in limbo until the council takes “dispositive” action or the mayor withdraws the name.
The charter also contains a never-used provision: if three mayoral nominees are rejected, the council may submit its own slate of three candidates, from which the mayor must choose one, Carl told the Star Tribune.
The vote that fractured the coalition
Last week’s rejection caught many by surprise. Two moderate Democrats who represent North Side wards — LaTrisha Vetaw and Pearll Warren — broke with the mayor to deny Peterson the seven votes needed for confirmation. Vetaw, typically a reliable Frey ally, told the Star Tribune she preferred another finalist, Deputy Chief of Investigations Charlie Adams, a North Side native she believes is more qualified. Warren cited two open misconduct complaints against Peterson.

Progressive council members, including President Elliott Payne, Robin Wonsley, Soren Stevenson, Jason Chavez, Aisha Chughtai and Aurin Chowdhury, voted no after a three-hour public hearing in which they pressed Peterson to identify specific examples of racist, sexist, homophobic or discriminatory behavior he had witnessed over his three decades on the force, the Star Tribune reported. Several said he failed to do so.
Council Member Aurin Chowdhury said she was disappointed by Peterson’s inability to name racial bias within the department or weaknesses in former Chief Brian O’Hara’s leadership. “You can’t fix present problems if you cannot acknowledge them,” she said in a statement to KSTP.
Soren Stevenson, a Ward 8 council member and survivor of MPD violence, told KSTP his concerns were unchanged. “We have to keep in mind that the Minneapolis Police Department is known on an international stage for a documented pattern of racism, discrimination and excessive use of force, as confirmed by a federal and state consent decree,” Stevenson said.
“After meeting with Chief Peterson and hearing his answers during the public hearings for his nomination, I reached the conclusion that unfortunately he is not the right person for this role.”
Community mediation team criticizes mayoral intervention
The Unity Community Mediation Team, a diverse group of south Minneapolis residents and business owners, sent a letter to Frey this week criticizing his intervention in the search.
“By appearing to have moved a favored candidate late into this process and including only a very few community members in the later stages of the process, you have hurt your reputation for community engagement with our most justice-impacted communities, and you have severely damaged the trust our residents placed in you in the last election,” wrote the Rev. Ian Bethel.

Bethel told CBS News that residents had made clear Peterson was not their choice, “mainly because many saw the process to get the nomination as flawed.” He noted the city spent nearly $90,000 on a search team only for the mayor to nominate an internal candidate late in the process.
Police leadership closes ranks
Peterson’s support among law enforcement peers remains overwhelming. At Monday’s BCA meeting, BCA Superintendent Drew Evans praised Peterson’s leadership since he took control of the department in May, and dozens of chiefs and high-ranking officials encouraged him to continue seeking the job, according to the Star Tribune. Some gave him a standing ovation.
“If I didn’t have 100% confidence in his abilities, I wouldn’t support him, because the city is too important for that,” Martin told the Star Tribune.
Frey sent an email to MPD officers and civilian staff Thursday emphasizing his desire that Peterson eventually be confirmed. “Going forward, I want to be clear that Interim Chief Peterson remains in charge of the department, and he has my full support,” the mayor wrote, according to the Star Tribune.
“He will continue serving as Interim Chief, and it is my continued hope that he will become the permanent chief of the Minneapolis Police Department.”
What happens Friday
The council meets Friday to consider overriding the veto. Without nine votes, the override fails and the nomination lingers in the charter’s uncharted territory. Someone could move to approve Peterson outright, or the council could postpone to a future meeting.
Carl said the charter’s design is “sort of brilliant” — forcing both branches to compromise. “It says both sides of this government need to come to the table and find a way to work together, even when it’s hard,” he told the Star Tribune.
Frey, born in Arlington County, Virginia, and raised in nearby Oakton, moved to Minneapolis in 2009 after graduating from Villanova University School of Law. He worked as an employment discrimination and civil rights attorney before winning a City Council seat in 2013.
Elected mayor in 2017, he became the city’s second Jewish mayor and its second-youngest. In 2021, voters approved a charter amendment creating a “strong mayor” system that gave him direct control over 11 departments; Frey is the first mayor to serve under that structure.
Peterson told department commanders Thursday he was exhausted after two marathon hearings but attempting to stay positive, the Star Tribune reported. He reiterated his commitment to the agency regardless of the outcome.