Gary Neville has told Manchester United’s incoming manager Mauricio Pochettino to offload Noussair Mazraoui, Lisandro Martínez and Matthijs de Ligt before making any decision on Diogo Dalot’s future, the Manchester United legend said on the “Stick to United” programme.
Neville argued that Dalot has become an easy target for criticism while playing behind a defence he described as a disaster, and he urged Pochettino to judge the Portuguese full-back only after the unit around him is rebuilt.
“I think if he was playing in a good defence, he would be in a better position, but his defence is a disaster,” Neville told Mark Goldbridge. “His position isn’t ideal, and he can improve on the ball and in everything he does, but I think he has become far too easy a target for criticism.”
The three Neville wants gone
Neville would start his rebuild by moving on Mazraoui, Martínez and De Ligt, insisting their futures need reviewing far more urgently than Dalot’s. “I would get rid of Mazraoui long before Dalot, and Martínez as well, and De Ligt too,” he said.
On De Ligt, Neville pointed to availability: “He has a big problem because he doesn’t play football, and if a player is injury-prone and doesn’t play regularly, you can’t favour him over a player who plays every week. You want a player you can rely on and who plays consistently.”
Martínez would go without hesitation, Neville stressed, repeating his stance on the Argentinian despite the defender continuing to feature for United this season after criticising the club’s management in a controversial interview last month. That interview has made Martínez one of the most talked-about names in the debate over the back line’s future.
🚨💰 Gary Neville: "Pochettino needs to make sure he takes the club into his own hands, into his own destiny, make sure he controls his own outcomes and make sure he's absolutely unequivocal in getting money to improve the defence initially in January and improving the midfield… pic.twitter.com/2bNfQa5c0P”
The core Neville would keep
Neville named Luke Shaw, Harry Maguire, Leny Yoro and Dalot as the four defenders Pochettino should retain. Shaw deserves a fresh chance under a coach who knows him well, though his injury record means United will still need to sign a left-back.
“He’ll keep Shaw because he knows him well, and he can perhaps get the best out of him, but his problem is injuries, so he’ll have to manage him carefully, and he’ll also need to sign a left-back,” Neville said.
Maguire stays because Pochettino may trust him to carry out the required defensive tasks. Yoro, despite looking slight and lacking physical balance at times — Neville likened his movement to Bambi on ice — has potential that can be developed.
The Frenchman’s call-up to the national team shows that potential, even if it hasn’t surfaced at United yet. Neville pointed to Rio Ferdinand, who added strength after Sir Alex Ferguson spotted the need, and insisted Yoro could follow the same path if he builds his physique.
Three new signings minimum
To build a back line capable of competing, Neville concluded Pochettino will need to sign at least three new defenders. Shaw, Maguire, Yoro and Dalot stay; Mazraoui, De Ligt and Martínez go.
The remarks come as United prepare for a period of change under Pochettino, with the defensive overhaul Neville outlined now the clearest public blueprint for the summer window.