Homeowners Accuse Phoenix of “Backroom Deals” in $11 Million Data Center Claim

Ahwatukee homeowners filed a notice of claim November 20 seeking $11 million in damages over Phoenix data center construction.

Ahwatukee homeowners are planning a legal challenge regarding the Phoenix data center construction.

The dispute centers on the massive Menlo Digital hyperscale data center, which occupies a 38-acre site across from hundreds of homes in Ahwatukee. This isn’t just a local zoning fight; it touches on the rapid, energy-intensive expansion of digital infrastructure in the Valley.

The notice of claim, filed on November 20, asks for $11 million in damages. This figure breaks down into $1 million for two households alleging lost property value, and $10 million in nuisance damages for neighbors in the Ahwatukee Community Alliance group, covering issues like noise, lights, pollution, traffic, and heat.

Life Disrupted by Ground Vibrations

Tom Branch, an Ahwatukee resident who has lived in his home for nearly 30 years, said that moving isn’t a real option right now. “Of course, we thought about it, but it’s a tough market right now for selling and buying, and it’s not really much of an option for us,” said Branch.

Powering Fifty-Eight Thousand Homes

The facility itself is immense: a 1 million-square-foot computer warehouse, exceeding half the size of State Farm Stadium. It’s built to generate 257 megawatts, enough to power roughly 58,000 Arizona homes during the summer months, unless the residents successfully intervene.

Homeowners Accuse Phoenix of "Backroom Deals" in $11 Million Data Center Claim
Photo: yahoo.com

Allegations of Expedited Approvals

Attorneys and residents believe the project moved too fast, suggesting permits were rubber-stamped and zoning restrictions were worked around through what they term shady backroom deals.

“These people’s lives currently are being disrupted. Have you ever sat in your home while the ground is vibrating from earth movers? This is a problem,” said Jacob Leavitt, attorney.

Anthony Ramirez, an Ahwatukee resident and attorney involved in the claim, clarified the group’s focus, pushing back against external characterizations. “There are people that think that you know there this group is an environmental group, and anti-technology, and that’s not it at all but this is like I said this is about a data center being built right across the street from homes,” said Ramirez.

Homeowners fight 38-acre Menlo Digital data center project — FOX 10 Phoenix

The Economic Stakes in Suburbia

The core tension here is the conflict between massive technological growth and established residential stability; the brunt falls on long-term homeowners who lack easy exit strategies in a tight real estate market.

The Counter Argument to Digital Growth

Opponents of the project aren’t against all technology, as Ramirez stressed, but specifically the placement of this intensive digital infrastructure right next to established neighborhoods.

“We’d like to get it stopped. It shouldn’t be built here in the first place. I don’t care if they store hay in that building, but I don’t want it to be a data center,” said Branch.

Menlo Digital launched in July 2025 as a dedicated data center platform from Menlo Equities, a firm founded in 1994 with three decades of real estate investment experience. Since developing its first data center in Santa Clara in 1998, the parent company has built a portfolio across major U.S. markets including Phoenix.

The group has 180 days from the November 20 filing date to file an actual lawsuit, according to reports from focalnews.org and yahoo.com.

The city of Phoenix stated it cannot comment on pending litigation when reached for a response.