“I was really impressed with the process that they have here in Minnehaha County,” Chris Karr said Thursday.
The Republican incumbent and Senate president pro tempore will keep his District 11 seat after a recount left the 35-vote margin over Democrat Aaron Matson untouched.
The Minnehaha County Auditor’s Office confirmed Thursday that Karr finished with 4,210 votes to Matson’s 4,175 out of 8,385 cast in the southwestern Sioux Falls district. A three-member recount board — referee Tyler Haigh, a Republican attorney appointed by a local judge, plus one Republican and one Democratic member — ran every ballot back through the tabulators and verified each stamp and duplicate.
South Dakota law allows a losing candidate to request a recount when the gap is 2% or less of the total votes in a Senate race. Matson’s 0.4% deficit easily qualified. “I think it was as expected,” Haigh said Thursday. “You don’t expect to find a lot of discrepancies, but if you find a discrepancy, then it’s the recount board’s obligation to look at why there’s the discrepancy.”
The unchanged result locks in a 92–12–1 Republican–Democratic–independent split for the legislative session that convenes January 12 in Pierre. Matson was not present for the recount. His attorney, Thad Titze, framed the outcome as a validation of the system.
“We’re disappointed about the election result, but really we’re not disappointed about the recount result,” Titze said Thursday. “This is exactly what you want to show that the process is fair and it works really well.”

Karr, who has held the seat since 2017, echoed that confidence. “I learned a great deal about the integrity of the process,” he told KELO-TV. The recount board’s work — checking eligibility, stamp placement, and voter intent on mismarked ovals — produced no net change for either candidate.
District 11 covers western Sioux Falls. The 35-vote margin amounted to less than half a percentage point, underscoring how a handful of ballots can swing chamber leadership in a supermajority legislature.