How the Indianapolis Colts' 2026 Rookie Class Is Faring Through Eight Games

How the Indianapolis Colts’ 2026 Rookie Class Is Faring Through Eight Games

by

The growing pains of a rebuilding roster

CJ Allen finally made his long-awaited first start for the Indianapolis Colts against the Jacksonville Jaguars, and while the defense struggled, the second-round linebacker provided a rare bright spot. After navigating multiple injuries that hampered his preseason and the early weeks of the schedule, Allen recorded 10 tackles, a tackle for loss, and his first career sack. According to a report from SI.com, Allen’s role remains relatively small for now, as he has played just 11 defensive snaps over the last two games while rotating behind Akeem Davis-Gaither.

As the 2026 season passes the eight-game mark, the Colts find themselves in a period of evaluation. The roster is caught between the immediate needs of a competitive season and the long-term necessity of developing a young core. For many of the rookies drafted this year, the first half of the season has been defined by flashes of potential interrupted by injury or a lack of consistent playing time.

The stakes for these young players extend beyond individual stats; they represent the foundation of the franchise’s future. With veteran players like Quenton Nelson potentially moving on and other roster shifts looming, the performance of this draft class will dictate how quickly Indianapolis can transition from a rebuilding phase to a contender.

Defensive development and individual struggles

While Allen is finding his footing, other defensive rookies are facing steeper climbs. AJ Haulcy has started all eight games at strong safety alongside Cam Bynum, but his production has lagged behind expectations. SI.com noted that Haulcy has dealt with issues involving missed tackles and has surrendered 16.2 yards per catch on five receptions in coverage. Through eight games, the 22-year-old LSU product has tallied just 22 tackles and two passes defended.

The linebacker depth chart remains a revolving door of sorts due to various injuries. Bryce Boettcher has logged 25 tackles through six games, though only eight have been solo efforts. While he has not been a liability when thrown into action, he has missed the last two games due to injury. Meanwhile, Caden Curry has yet to record a sack, but his impact is often felt in ways the stat sheet misses. SI.com reported that Curry has played 55 snaps on special teams, and head coach Shane Steichen recently praised his tenacity following a game against the Jaguars.

Edge rusher George Gumbs Jr. remains a project for the coaching staff. Drafted with the understanding that he was a work in progress, Gumbs has been limited by injuries, appearing in only four games this season. The organization appears content to let him continue his development without the pressure of a heavy workload.

Offensive shifts and emerging roles

The offensive side of the ball is undergoing significant changes, particularly following the trade of All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson to the Seahawks. This move forced rookie Jalen Farmer into action in Week 8. Although the offensive line struggled to find its rhythm without Nelson, Farmer showed glimpses of the power that made him a fourth-round selection.

How the Indianapolis Colts' 2026 Rookie Class Is Faring Through Eight Games

The backfield is also seeing a shift in dynamics. Seth McGowan, a late-round pick, has become the primary backup to Jonathan Taylor. Through eight games, McGowan has recorded 163 rushing yards on 37 attempts, averaging 4.4 yards per carry. If trade rumors involving Taylor materialize, McGowan could see a significant increase in responsibility.

How the Indianapolis Colts' 2026 Rookie Class Is Faring Through Eight Games

On the receiving corps, Deion Burks is working his way up from special teams. While he has only seen eight touches for 81 scrimmage yards, he has been efficient, converting three of those touches into first downs. His role could expand significantly if the team addresses the future of Josh Downs.

Player Position Key Stat (Through 8 Games)
CJ Allen LB 10 tackles vs. Jaguars
AJ Haulcy S 22 total tackles
Seth McGowan RB 163 rushing yards
Deion Burks WR 81 scrimmage yards

The upcoming weeks will serve as a litmus test for these players. The coaching staff is balancing the need to win now with the necessity of giving these rookies the reps required to prepare for 2027 and beyond. The most immediate deadline to watch is November 10, the date by which any potential trade request from Josh Downs must be addressed, which would directly impact the offensive deployment of players like Burks.

Worth a look

Read next