HSE Chief Accuses CUH of Conducting Management Business Through Media

HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor will tell the Oireachtas Health Committee today that Cork University Hospital is “conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity,” an escalation of a row that has pitted the hospital’s clinical leadership against the health service’s national directors.

The confrontation centres on a warning CUH chief executive Jennifer Kearney sent to the HSE in August: a shortfall of roughly 1,000 staff meant the hospital would not be safe heading into winter. Nine clinical directors backed her assessment.

O’Connor’s prepared opening statement, reported by RTÉ, rejects the safety narrative. “Their increase in staffing this year is bigger than the combined increase in Beaumont, the Mater, St James and Tallaght University hospitals,” she will say.

“We need to change the working environment [at CUH] that has been created recently so we can engage respectfully and professionally and work together through the coming months for the benefit of the patients that we serve,”

Anne O’Connor, HSE Chief Executive

The recording that changed the story

The dispute took a sharper turn after a meeting in August between HSE South West regional executive officer Andy Phillips and senior CUH figures was recorded and leaked.

Official minutes quoted Phillips telling Kearney he had been instructed by the offices of the Taoiseach and the Minister for Health “to have some very specific conversations with you.” Phillips initially denied the remarks, then apologised “unreservedly” after The Irish Times obtained a tape confirming the minutes were accurate.

O’Connor told RTÉ’s This Week on Sunday that Phillips made the comments “in a fit of frustration in terms of the discussion that went on that day.” She said she retains confidence in him but warned a culture has taken root where staff are “fearful of going to meetings because they fear they may be recorded.”

HSE chief executive Anne O'Connor (right) with Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill. Photograph: Sam Boal/Collins
Photo: The Irish Times

Taoiseach denies instructing Phillips

Taoiseach Micheál Martin strongly denied that he or his staff gave any such instruction to Phillips. Speaking to reporters on Monday, he said he was “very concerned” about the recording because “my understanding is that not everybody knew they were being recorded. It’s no way, in my view, to conduct conversations and discussions.”

He dismissed the idea of punishing whoever made the recording, calling it “symptomatic of problems, it would seem to me, or interpersonal issues, or issues between different areas of responsibility within the broader HSE group.”

Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has repeatedly dismissed the staffing concerns, saying CUH hired twice as many staff as budgeted for and suggesting the hospital was not managing its affairs properly.

Social Democrats TD Liam Quaide, who sits on the health committee, called O’Connor’s planned statement “a deeply troubling attempt to discredit those who have raised legitimate concerns about patient safety at CUH.”

“CUH’s clinical leadership has repeatedly raised these concerns through established management channels. Their warnings have not resulted in necessary action. In speaking publicly, they are upholding their professional and ethical duty to protect patients,”

Liam Quaide, Social Democrats TD for Cork East

Quaide added that blaming CUH management for the working environment “is yet another attempt to turn the people raising the alarm into the problem.” The hospital sits in the Taoiseach’s own Dáil constituency.

HSE Chief Accuses CUH of Conducting Management Business Through Media
Photo: Irish Examiner

Hiqa visit finds CUH safety comparable

Martin pointed to an unannounced Hiqa visit which found CUH “in line with other hospitals in respect of patient safety,” arguing “we can’t have alternative processes that determine patient safety, other than the established ones.” As of Friday, 45 patients were waiting for beds at CUH — the third-highest trolley count in the country behind University Hospital Limerick and University Hospital Galway.

The Cabinet approved almost €800 million in supplementary funding for the HSE yesterday. O’Connor will tell the committee the service faces “a very serious financial position” where “the gap between HSE spending and funding has grown over a number of years.” She said recruitment controls, agency restrictions and expenditure thresholds introduced since she took over have begun to moderate spending growth, with six consecutive months of reduction in agency costs.

The committee hears O’Connor at 9.30am.