“Maybe we could leave like a couple of cars here or something like that,” 10-year-old Kane Garcia said Thursday, summing up the sentiment that forced the Huntsville City Council to hit pause on a plan to clear the historic depot of its railcars.
The council voted Thursday to postpone a decision on the fate of historic railroad equipment at the Huntsville Depot until its Dec. 3 meeting, following an outcry from residents who want the artifacts to remain on the 1860 property. Councilwoman Michelle Watkins requested the delay after receiving messages from constituents concerned about the proposed transfers.
“That’ll give us time to address the concerns of the constituents that have reached out,” Watkins said during the meeting.

The city’s Planning Department had proposed donating nine pieces of equipment to the North Alabama Railroad Museum and selling three others, according to WAFF. Two of the pieces slated for sale could be incorporated into a proposed commercial electric vehicle charging station. The inventory includes historic railcars, cabooses, a steam locomotive and other railroad artifacts.
Yahoo News, citing WHNT, reported a slightly different breakdown: the proposal involved donating three of six railroad cars to the museum, with the remaining three cars still up for discussion by the council.
City Administrator John Hamilton said the equipment needs significant restoration, but the city has neither the funding nor the specialized expertise to complete that work. Council members questioned whether the city could instead loan the equipment to the museum, allowing Huntsville to retain ownership. Hamilton said that approach would require reconsidering the arrangement because the museum would be investing in equipment it does not own.
Mark Hillgartner, president of the North Alabama Railroad Museum, said the organization has already planned how to refurbish the pieces.
“We’ve already discussed what we can do to refurbish them and make them better condition than what they currently are,” Hillgartner said. “We’ve been doing this for 60 years, and if the equipment does come to NARM, we will be good stewards for it.”
Hillgartner said the equipment would remain in Huntsville, approximately five miles from its current location at the museum, where visitors could see it free of charge during daylight hours alongside roughly 40 other pieces already on display. He told WHNT the museum is the only organization in the area that understands what to do with the cars and the value they hold for North Alabama residents.
Residents and historians argued the issue is about more than accessibility. John H. Allen, a past president of the Huntsville Historical Society, criticized the city’s stewardship.
“I’ve lived in a lot of cities in Alabama, moving around in my various jobs, and I’ve never known a city to have so little regard for its historical heritage as the depot,” Allen said.
Local historian Arlie McCormick emphasized the depot’s wider importance. The building dates to the Civil War era, and the railroad helped shape Huntsville’s development.
“My biggest interest is retaining the structures, so we can educate teenagers, the adults, the new people in town about what this area meant to us in this city as it grew,” McCormick said.
The Huntsville Depot, completed in 1860, is the oldest surviving railroad depot in Alabama and one of the oldest in the United States. During the Civil War, Union forces occupied the building in 1862 and used it as a prison for Confederate soldiers, whose graffiti remains visible on the third-floor walls.
The property served as a museum under the EarlyWorks Museums system until October 2024, when operations ceased and control reverted to the City of Huntsville.
Some residents suggested turning the depot itself into a museum rather than dispersing the collection. The council will take up the matter again Dec. 3.