ND Farmer Pleads Guilty to Crop Insurance Fraud; Sentencing Set for March 24

A North Dakota farmer pleaded guilty to crop insurance fraud involving more than $347,000; sentencing is scheduled for March 24.

More than $347,000 in federal crop insurance payments went to a North Dakota farmer who overreported production on some fields and underreported it on others, a scheme prosecutors call “shifting production.”

Joseph Fettig, 51, of Tappen pleaded guilty Thursday in U.S. District Court in Bismarck to one count of making false statements to influence the USDA Risk Management Agency, InsuranceNewsNet reported. The plea agreement calls for restitution of $208,000 — a 40 percent reduction from the original loss figure — and a five-year ban from all USDA programs, but no prison time.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Jonathan O’Konek said special investigators with the Risk Management Agency compared Fettig’s crop reports against harvest data recorded by his machinery, finding irregularities across three units of land in Logan County that Fettig farmed in 2022. When confronted, Fettig stopped making false reports, O’Konek told the court.

“That’s a significant penalty.”

O’Konek said of the recommended sentence, which includes three years of supervised release. Federal sentencing guidelines call for one to one-and-a-half years in prison based on the monetary loss and Fettig’s lack of criminal history, he said, but Fettig’s early guilty plea and agreement to pay restitution drove the government’s recommendation for probation.

Joseph Fettig 2.jpg
Photo: bismarcktribune.com

Defense attorney Gary Leistico argued that farm machinery harvest data is routinely inaccurate by as much as 40 percent, and that the $347,000 total should be reduced accordingly. O’Konek said reducing the figure by that margin to reach $208,000 was acceptable.

U.S. District Judge Daniel Hovland accepted Fettig’s guilty plea and deferred acceptance of the plea agreement pending a presentence investigation. Sentencing is scheduled for March 24.

The Federal Crop Insurance Corporation, created during the New Deal after the Dust Bowl devastated farm production in the 1930s, manages the federal crop insurance program that provides U.S. farmers with protection against yield losses. Between 1980 and 2005, the corporation recorded $43.6 billion in total claims, with three-quarters stemming from drought, excess moisture and hail.

U.S. Attorney Nick Chase said Fettig made false statements to the Risk Management Agency and Federal Crop Insurance Corporation that manufactured and inflated crop insurance protections on his corn production in Logan County, KFGO reported.