Twenty years ago, on a Monday morning in downtown Huntsville, a school bus carrying Lee High School students plunged from the Interstate 565 overpass onto Church Street below, killing four girls and injuring dozens more.
The crash, which occurred November 20, 2006, remains a tragedy the city remembers, WAFF reported. A student driving a Toyota alongside the bus on the ramp attempted to pass and clipped the bus, according to the National Transportation Safety Board. The bus driver lost control and was thrown from the vehicle; with no one at the wheel, the bus skidded along a concrete rail before falling nose-first onto the street.
Crystal McCrary, Nicole Ford, Tanesha Hill and Christine Collier — all seated in the first two rows — were killed. Thirty-four people were injured, including the bus driver and three of the girls who were ejected, WAFF reported, citing the NTSB findings. Six passengers in total were thrown from the bus.
“Time heals… but not completely. It never goes away. That will never be forgotten.”
Dr. Theresa Gurley, a Lee High School counselor who rushed to Huntsville Hospital that morning, told WAFF. “Is it still traumatic today? Definitely. You can only learn to manage things.”

The scene at the hospital
Laura Collier arrived at the emergency room to be told her only child, Felicia, had died — her student ID had been found near Christine Collier’s body. The girls were not related. Minutes later, staff corrected the news: Felicia had survived with head trauma, a punctured lung and broken bones requiring multiple surgeries. She does not remember the crash and still cannot speak about it, her mother said.
“It was terrible. So many grieving parents and students. It was overwhelming,” Laura Collier told WAFF.
New patient-tracking and trauma bay improvements follow tragedy
HEMSI’s Don Webster was among the first on scene. “How in the world did this happen?” he recalled thinking. Responders faced a chaotic triage without a bus roster or reliable passenger count. The tragedy prompted a new patient-tracking system: “We now use a tagging system and everybody has a number and that number is recorded electronically where we can keep up and account for them,” Webster told WAFF.
Huntsville Hospital later renovated its emergency room, creating larger trauma bays so more patients could be treated simultaneously — a direct legacy of the influx that morning.
The seat-belt debate
Then-Gov. Bob Riley ordered a study of school bus safety, including whether seat belts should be retrofitted. The 2007 study group concluded retrofitting was not the most cost-effective safety improvement, WAFF reported.
Instead, the group recommended a pilot program equipping ten new buses with lap-and-shoulder belts pending new federal design standards from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, WAFF reported. No criminal charges were filed against the bus driver or the student driver; civil lawsuits on behalf of students were successful.
Living memory
For years, teddy bears and mementos lined the fence beneath the overpass. An old key ring bearing the word “FAITH” remains there still. Sade Flemings, best friend of one of the girls killed, said she wakes each anniversary knowing the date.
“I know that day I saw her in the hallway that morning when she was going to the bus… I was giving her that notebook that we traced and she’s supposed to respond to me, you know, of course, I never got a chance to get that because she died,” Flemings said.
Survivor Seville Briggs described the moment the bus went over the rail: “It just hit it and then it went over, but as I was going over, I kind of just grabbed the bottom of my seat… I just feel people just flying all over it. And then when it fell down, you know, the glass, the glass hit, everybody was just all over the place.”
“The ones who were lost tragically let their families know that we’re always thinking of them. And that is not a day that that we know that their names are, you know, not being mentioned or that we have forgotten,” Flemings said.
Lee High School opened in 1957 as a junior high and became a full high school in 1964, graduating its first class that year. The school added Arts and Pre-Engineering magnet programs in 1986, and its Marching Generals band was the first from Huntsville City Schools to lead the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade in 1984.
Huntsville City Schools issued a statement marking the anniversary: “As we mark the 20th anniversary of the 2006 Lee High School bus tragedy, Huntsville City Schools remembers the four students who lost their lives and the many others who were impacted. Our thoughts remain with their families, loved ones, and the Lee High School community.”