I Interviewed 40 California Candidates; Most Couldn’t Answer Basic Questions

Over the past year, I interviewed roughly 40 candidates running for offices ranging from local city controller seats to the U.S. Congress.

It was an eye-opening exercise that revealed a troubling deficit in the quality of leadership offered to California voters. While a handful of candidates displayed a firm grasp of policy, the majority were either unserious, deeply uninformed, or burdened by significant personal red flags.

The stakes of these elections are immense. Politicians are responsible for the allocation of public tax dollars and the overall well-being of millions of residents. Yet, my experience suggests that many who seek office fail to appreciate the weight of these responsibilities. When a candidate cannot articulate a rational basis for their own campaign promises, they effectively leave the public guessing about their actual intent—or lack thereof.

Candidates Spread Conspiracy Theories

The spectrum of inadequacy I encountered was broad. Some candidates, such as Imperial Mayor Ida Obeso-Martinez, who was running for the state Assembly, seemed genuinely surprised that they were expected to answer substantive policy questions.

Others, like congressional candidate Mike Cargile, utilized their platforms to propagate bizarre conspiracy theories, including a claim about the government using ticks to spread Alpha-gal syndrome. These instances were not rare outliers; they were persistent features of the election cycle.

Even when candidates were pressed for clarity, the response was often hostility rather than policy defense. El Cajon mayoral candidate Alexander Kraft became audibly upset when asked to explain his support for the total dismantling of capitalism. His opponent, Mayor Bill Wells, also bristled at the inquiry. This aversion to scrutiny is a systemic issue, one that transcends party lines.

I Interviewed 40 California Candidates; Most Couldn't Answer Basic Questions
Photo: pressenterprise.com

Remember: when you hear a campaign promise, those candidates often don’t have good reasons for believing those promises and often have no plans to fulfill them. I’ve asked them. Both Democrats and Republicans. They don’t know why or whether those promises are good ideas.

The Burden of the Ballot

There were exceptions to this trend. Matt Mahan, a gubernatorial candidate, demonstrated a clear, data-driven approach to the housing crisis, bolstered by his record as mayor of San Jose. Similarly, Los Angeles mayoral candidate Adam Miller offered concrete strategies for addressing homelessness. These individuals provided a glimpse of what rigorous preparation looks like, yet they remained the exception rather than the rule.

The Republican Party, in particular, struggled to field candidates who could engage in reality-based discourse. The frequency with which GOP candidates relied on falsehoods or fringe theories was notably higher than that of their Democratic counterparts.

This lack of balance in candidate quality makes it difficult for voters to hold the system accountable. When every option on the ballot is flawed, the voter is forced into a painful process of selecting the “least bad” candidate rather than the most qualified.

After being asked to defend his record during our interview, he later complained to other members of the media about the “hard questions” posed to him. His reaction suggests a fundamental misunderstanding of the role of a public servant in a democracy. If a candidate cannot defend their views during a campaign, there is little reason to believe they will do so while in office.

Ultimately, the quality of our governance is a direct reflection of the candidates we are given to choose from. When politicians treat their duties with flippancy and voters are presented with a field of candidates who struggle to articulate even the most basic rationalizations for their positions, the entire civic process suffers.