Iowa City leaders will decide on Tuesday, Nov. 17, whether to let St. Mary’s Catholic Church demolish two historic downtown buildings to make room for a new parish center.
The Iowa City Council is set to consider appealing its decision to bar the church from demolishing structures located at 302 and 306 E. Jefferson St., according to The Daily Iowan. Church officials want to replace the current parish offices with a modern ministry facility, but the plan has sparked a sharp clash between parish growth and local preservation efforts.
Both properties sit inside the Jefferson Street Historic District and carry listings on the National Registry of Historic Places. Because of that protective status, demolishing them requires proving the structures are completely unrecoverable. The Iowa City Historic Preservation Commission voted 4-3 on Oct. 8 to deny the demolition permit, prompting the church to file an appeal with the city council.
The demolition request forms a core piece of the church’s $10 million “Foundations of Faith Campaign.” The wider fundraising effort also covers interior repairs to the historic church and parish hall, alongside accessibility upgrades.
Andrew Rauenbuehler, pastor of the church, defended the project during the Oct. 8 preservation commission meeting. “We do not see this project simply as the replacement of two old buildings,” Rauenbuehler told The Daily Iowan. “We see it as an opportunity to make a significant and historic investment in both St. Mary’s and in the wider Iowa City community.”
Church leaders argue that structural engineers have deemed both buildings unsound. They also point to surging attendance as an urgent operational need. Parishioners say the new center would give the growing congregation enough space to run concurrent programs like youth ministry and bible studies.
“We have experienced firsthand how Father Andrew has brought tremendous life and community back to the church, filling the pews every Sunday and drawing in new members, especially high school students and university young adults, alongside long-time parishioners,” Morgan Proctor, a long-time parishioner, wrote in an email included in the city council’s Nov. 2 agenda packet.
Not everyone in the neighborhood supports clearing the site, however. Preservation advocates argue that removing the buildings would punch a permanent hole in the historic streetscape.
Dana Thomann, an Iowa City resident, spoke against the demolition at the October commission meeting. “We have a lot of broken-out teeth, even cavities around here, because we are not following our guidelines that we set,” Thomann told The Daily Iowan.
The city council will hear final arguments and take up the appeal during its 6 p.m. meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 17.