Idaho’s smallest hospitals are being forced to pay for grant writers to compete for federal money meant to keep their doors open, a dynamic that surfaced Thursday as state officials explained why the state’s share of a $50 billion rural health program shrank by $3 million in its second year.
Juliet Charron, director of the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare, told legislators and a provider task force in Boise that the state received $182.7 million for year two of the Rural Health Transformation Program, down from $186 million in year one.
Charron said staff are still trying to determine how the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services allocated the points that drove the reduction. A revised budget reflecting the lower amount is due to federal authorities by Nov. 30.
The drop puts Idaho out of step with neighboring Montana, which saw its award grow from $233 million to $239.7 million over the same period. The program was created in July 2025 through the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which also cut an estimated nearly $1 trillion in Medicaid spending over ten years.
Winners describe transformative impact
More than $103.5 million of the first-year funds went to hospitals and clinics for infrastructure, equipment and technology upgrades. For recipients, the money is plugging gaps that operating margins never could.

“The (electronic health record software), this is transformative for us. This is something that for us to do on our own, would take almost all our cash on reserves.”
said Brad Turpen, CEO of Valor Health in Emmett. The hospital received two awards totaling more than $5.4 million for a new electronic health record system designed to connect with larger regional hospitals and for new imaging equipment.
At Bonner General Health, the 25-bed facility that is the only hospital in Boundary County, CEO John Hennessy said the grant will fund four new surgical suites. The existing operating room was at full capacity, forcing patients to wait or travel elsewhere for procedures. Hennessy said surgical volume is expected to increase 23% in the first year with the added space.
Losers say the process favored polish over need
Several small providers who were denied funding told the task force they never received an explanation for their scores. Steve Rembelski, CEO of the Challis Area Health Center, said his application was marked down for a lack of innovation.

“We were scored down for ‘innovative,’ … when you’re replacing roofs or hospital beds, I was perplexed in terms of I don’t know how to make that innovative for a basic need.”
Rembelski said.
Brad Huerta, CEO of Lost Rivers Medical Center in Arco, said his eastern Idaho hospital cooperative shared a broader concern: facilities that could not afford professional grant writers lost out.
“The perception, I’m just letting the committee know, was that grants that were written pretty got funded. Grants that had genuine need were not funded.”
Huerta said. “There’s a lot of genuine, real rural hospitals that don’t have that ability. If you do have $1, we’re using them to hire nurses or CNAs. We’re one deep on the bench in a lot of these things, and we just don’t have the ability to hire a grant writer.”
Beau McNeff, CEO of Weiser Memorial Hospital, said he plans to hire a grant writer for the next cycle. “I really do feel like in order for us to be competitive this next year, we’re going to have to pay somebody,” McNeff said.
“Those are dollars that we could be using on something else. But in order to try and be competitive and secure dollars that we desperately need, we’re going to have to divert some to support that.”
State promises a simpler application
Charron acknowledged the disparity and said the agency is working to redesign the application process so smaller facilities can compete without hiring outside help. The department had to “sprint” to obligate the full first-year allotment, a pace that left little room for technical assistance to the smallest applicants.
The stakes are immediate. Idaho’s rural hospitals operate on razor-thin margins, often serving as the sole source of emergency and obstetric care for hundreds of miles. The federal program was intended to stabilize that infrastructure, but the first year suggests the mechanics of distribution may be reinforcing the very inequities the money was meant to fix.