Following the release of a drawing featuring New Mexico Gov.-elect Deb Haaland, the Indigenous Journalists Association (IJA) has urged the Albuquerque Journal to issue an apology and re-examine its editorial procedures.
The illustration, drawn by staff cartoonist John Trever and featured in the newspaper’s print edition on Nov. 8, utilized a totem pole as a visual trope.
The IJA, in a statement released on Nov. 12, argued that the cartoon relied on a cultural practice specific to Pacific Northwest tribes—the totem pole—and mistakenly applied it to Haaland, who is a citizen of the Pueblo of Laguna.
The association took issue with the fundamental premise of the work. By using a “totem pole” as a punch line for a Pueblo woman, the cartoon reinforced a concern among Native communities: the tendency of mainstream media to treat diverse Indigenous cultures as interchangeable.
While the IJA acknowledged that political cartoonists may scrutinize Haaland’s record and proposals, they emphasized that such commentary should hold public officials accountable without reducing them to racial caricatures.
The organization’s request is specific. They are asking the Albuquerque Journal to publish a printed and online apology, explain how the cartoon passed editorial review, and commit to staff training on how to report on Indigenous communities. The IJA suggests that the paper utilize resources like their own Indigenous Media Initiative.
As noted by the New Mexico Political Report, this is not the first time the Albuquerque Journal has faced backlash for its coverage of Haaland. The outlet also recalled a 2018 controversy involving a syndicated cartoon regarding the depiction of young immigrants.
Pointing out that Native individuals make up a portion of the publication’s neighbors, sources, and readership, the IJA asserted that these communities warrant the exact same level of respect, precision, and diligence afforded to any other group.
“The association said the cartoon reinforced the false idea that Indigenous peoples and cultures are interchangeable.”
As of Nov. 14, the Albuquerque Journal had not publicly responded to the IJA’s requests.