NYC Bus Fare Checkers Face Discipline After Violent Incidents

Some of the New York City bus fare checkers involved in two fare enforcement actions that turned physical face disciplinary action and possible termination, NYC Transit President Demetrius Crichlow told the Metropolitan Transportation Authority board on Monday.

The decision follows internal investigations into two separate incidents where members of the MTA’s Evasion and Graffiti Lawlessness Eradication teams were caught on video in violent episodes involving passengers during fare checks. All 350 EAGLE team members have been pulled from fare-checking duties since Oct. 22, pending the conclusion of the probes and a spate of re-trainings.

“The investigation is complete,” Crichlow said Monday. “What was captured on the video during these two incidents was unacceptable.”

“[Disciplinary] charges will be drafted against select individuals, and those charges could end up in discipline up to and including termination,” Crichlow continued.

The transit president said he would submit a letter to MTA Chairman Janno Lieber on Monday detailing the internal investigation, though that letter had not been made public as of press time. About half of NYC bus riders do not pay their fares.

As the New York Daily News previously disclosed, a quartet of EAGLE employees were shifted to different roles around the middle of October following security camera footage — initially brought to light by the New York Daily News — that captured them shoving Brooklyn school aide Kyle Taylor against a Brownsville bus shelter after he attempted to push past them, leading to a physical struggle.

Seven days later, MTA executives withdrew all EAGLE units from active duty after footage emerged detailing an August encounter in the Bronx where inspectors tried to restrain a commuter who insiders claimed became aggressive during a ticket inspection.

According to information provided to the New York Daily News, the individual was removed from the bus before coming back to threaten the operator, while an NYPD representative said that a formal harassment complaint had been lodged against the passenger.

Police were called during that incident, but MTA leadership was never notified of the altercation.

“Riders deserve complete confidence that our fare enforcement is fair and courteous,” Lieber said at the time. “Our EAGLE teams won’t be re-entering the field until I am confident that their training — and their reporting and investigation protocols — meet our high standards.”

Even though the probe has wrapped up, Crichlow said that the EAGLE personnel are not yet prepared to resume checking fares.

“There’s still more to do before we get these teams back to their full fare enforcement duties,” he said.

The EAGLE teams — whose 350 members are not peace officers under New York law — have been undergoing de-escalation training with members of the MTA Police Department, Crichlow said, and a source with knowledge confirmed. The transit boss also said the MTA would begin equipping EAGLE team members with body cameras as a pilot program.

Additional measures to revamp the initiative involve introducing fresh attire, restructuring reporting procedures within the security division of NYC Transit, and setting up a dedicated telephone line allowing riders to voice complaints concerning the fare-inspection staff.

“It is critical that we still have a mean of fare enforcement in the system,” Crichlow said. “No question, folks should pay their fare in order to ride the system — without their fares, the system doesn’t run.”