Independent Audit Suggests Changes to Wisconsin School District Report Cards

Wisconsin school report cards face scrutiny as an independent audit suggests changes are needed for statutory performance reporting in November 2026.

This 146-page review, issued by the Legislative Audit Bureau, analyzed public, charter, and private school report cards from 2022 through 2025, WPR reported. The core issue centers on whether the Department of Public Instruction’s scoring methods accurately convey school performance as required by statute.

The stakes here aren’t just bureaucratic; they touch directly on how Wisconsin families gauge their children’s education and how accountability is practically enforced across diverse districts.

Sen. Eric Wimberger, R-Gillett, and Rep. Robert Wittke, R-Caledonia, who chair the audit committee, stated, “DPI unilaterally turned school report cards into an untrustworthy sham.”

Ninety-five percent of Wisconsin public school districts received three, four, or five stars, reflecting meeting, exceeding, or significantly exceeding expectations, according to the audit.

Independent audit urges changes to wisconsin school report cards
Photo: commongoodnews.org

This difference arises because the DPI weighs student achievement and growth more heavily than raw student performance in calculating overall scores for low-income districts, a methodology signed into law by former Gov. Scott Walker, according to commongoodnews.org.

Critics argue this weighting makes direct, apples-to-apples comparisons between districts across the state impossible.

Controversy intensified in 2024 when DPI updated testing standards and “cut scores,” which determine the star scale placement, a change State Superintendent Jill Underly noted was needed to keep pace with performance measures.

Republicans and conservative groups, like the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty, have argued these updates lowered standards, though the audit itself does not explicitly confirm standards were lowered.

Wisconsin DPI releases school, district report cards — WEAU 13 News

The audit did find DPI’s assessment process isn’t creating conditions for necessary intervention when schools meet minimal performance standards.

The audit also found DPI should have released written policies to all stakeholders regarding testing changes, noting the department did not broadly solicit feedback from educators or the public before making adjustments.

The Legislative Audit Bureau made 13 recommendations to DPI, and the department must report on its implementation efforts by March 30, 2027, as noted by schoolinfosystem.org on its efforts to implement all of the recommendations.