Indiana Senate Republicans installed Chris Garten as their new leader Tuesday, hours after the state Supreme Court overturned a lower court order that had blocked him from taking the oath of office, according to Inside INdiana Business.
The unanimous ruling cleared Garten, a Republican from Charlestown, to be sworn in as Senate president pro tem on Organization Day, even as the vote tally in his own reelection race remains the subject of a Democratic legal challenge and a looming recount.
Garten won the District 45 seat by 297 votes over Democrat Nick Marshall — 21,817 to 21,520, a margin of roughly two-thirds of a percentage point — but Democrats argue that a ballot scanner malfunction at Jeffersonville High School, where four Clark County precincts voted, casts doubt on the accuracy of the count.
“What we witnessed was an extraordinary attempt to use the judicial system to prevent the people of an entire Senate district from having their elected representative take office.”
Garten told reporters after the swearing-in, calling the Democratic legal maneuver “lawfare.” He announced he had directed his legal team to file for a recount himself, saying he welcomed transparency and had complete confidence in the outcome.
The constitutional collision
Scott County Circuit Judge Jason Mount issued a temporary restraining order Monday prohibiting Garten from presenting himself for the oath, siding with Clark County Democratic Chairman David Drake, who argued the election board had failed to adequately investigate the scanner issues before certifying results.
Garten’s attorneys, led by prominent conservative lawyer James Bopp along with Ted Nolting and Philip Lashutka of Kroger, Gardis and Regas, filed an emergency appeal arguing Mount exceeded his authority. They cited Article 4, Section 10 of the Indiana Constitution, which states that “the respective houses of the legislature are the sole judges of the results of the elections of their members.”

The Supreme Court agreed, lifting the portion of Mount’s order blocking Garten’s seating while leaving intact the restraint on the Clark County Election Board certifying the county’s overall vote totals.
“The order stops the certification the recount statutes assume, and it purports to forbid a Senator-elect from presenting himself to the Senate,” Garten’s attorneys wrote in their filing. “That is a court impermissibly deciding who may be heard by the Senate on its organizing day.”
The factual core of the challenge involves a ballot scanner malfunction reported on Election Day at Jeffersonville High School. Democrats maintain the Clark County Election Board — controlled 2-1 by Republicans — failed to adequately review problems involving the four precincts that voted there. The board moved forward with the results despite the reported equipment issue, a decision Democrats say undermines confidence in the 297-vote margin.
Mount, a Democrat, was assigned as special judge after a Clark County judge recused. Mount is the brother of Republican U.S. Rep. Erin Houchin, who previously served in the state Senate with Garten — a connection that added a layer of political intrigue to the procedural fight.
A district in transition
The close race marks a sharp departure for Garten, who won his previous two general elections with more than 60 percent of the vote. District 45, covering all of Clark County and a portion of Floyd County in southeastern Indiana, was part of a trend this cycle where Democrats either won or came unusually close in several Republican-held districts.
That shift followed contentious debate over a failed effort to redraw the state’s congressional districts mid-decade — a push backed by President Donald Trump and Gov. Mike Braun that Garten supported. On Tuesday, Garten struck a conciliatory tone, preaching bipartisanship to address Indiana’s affordability challenges. “When you disagree, we can defend our convictions and we can still work together,” he said.
“It was very refreshing to hear the speech that we heard. I’m really excited that we’re going to work together.”
Senate Minority Leader Shelli Yoder, D-Bloomington, told reporters, adding she would trust the legal and recount processes to play out properly.

Recount commission review will determine outcome
Garten’s voluntary recount petition joins the Democratic challenge before the Indiana Recount Commission. State law requires the commission to complete a legislative recount by December 20, unless it extends the deadline for good cause. Candidates had until Tuesday to file petitions, with county party chairs facing a Friday deadline.
The commission’s review will determine whether the scanner malfunction — and the board’s handling of it — altered the outcome in a district that, until this cycle, was considered safely Republican. For now, Garten holds the gavel and the seat. The final count will decide if he keeps them.