Indiana Thanksgiving Dinner Costs Dropped 8% This Year

Indiana Thanksgiving dinner costs dropped 8% this year as turkey prices fell sharply, pushing the average meal for 10 below $50 for the first time since 2022.

The Bottom Line

  • Indiana Farm Bureau survey: $49.17 average for 10-person meal, down $4.45 from $53.62 in 2025.
  • Turkey drives the drop: 16-pound bird averages $19.38, 18% below the $23.68 national average.
  • Food-at-home inflation eases, but farmers’ share stuck at 12.6 cents per retail dollar.

The Indiana Farm Bureau’s annual market basket survey, conducted by volunteer shoppers in early November before holiday promotions began, found nearly every staple cheaper than a year ago. The $49.17 total compares with a national average of $58.63 tracked by the American Farm Bureau Federation, a gap of $9.46 or roughly 16%.

“Our shoppers in Indiana found their turkeys to be about 8% cheaper on average than they were in 2025,” said Todd Davis, chief economist at the Indiana Farm Bureau. “Which could be a result of a 6% increase in U.S. turkey production in 2026. Grocery stores could also be using a lower turkey price tag to get shoppers in the door to purchase the rest of their Thanksgiving items.”

Here are the average prices for a Thanksgiving meal in Indiana — FOX59 News

“Farmers are continuously finding ways to be agile and streamline their operation to produce healthy food families depend on for a holiday meal, despite rising input and labor costs,” Davis said in the bureau’s release. “Many consumers don’t realize that farmers are price-takers, just like them. Farmers don’t set the prices, and the amount farmers are being paid doesn’t cover the increase of their input expenses.”

Turkey Supply Recovery Anchors the Basket

Turkey accounts for roughly 40% of the meal’s total cost, making it the single largest lever on the final tab. The 16-pound bird averaged $19.38 in Indiana, down from $21.09 in 2025, according to the bureau’s itemized breakdown. Nationally, the same bird runs $23.68, putting Indiana 18% cheaper on the centerpiece alone.

U.S. turkey production rose 6% in 2026, the bureau noted, easing the supply constraints that followed highly pathogenic avian influenza outbreaks in prior years.

Pie Shells Drop 23 Percent

Pie shells led percentage declines, dropping 23% to $2.84. Frozen peas fell 20% to $1.44. Fresh cranberries slid 16% to $2.06. Pumpkin pie filling dropped 10% to $3.60. Whipping cream, stuffing, sweet potatoes, rolls, and the miscellaneous baking-ingredients bundle all posted single-digit declines.

Indiana Thanksgiving Dinner Costs Dropped 8% This Year
Photo: indianacapitalchronicle.com

Whole milk was the lone exception, rising 11 cents to $3.16 per gallon — a 4% increase year over year. Even so, Indiana’s milk price sits 22% below the national survey average.

Item 2025 Indiana Avg. 2026 Indiana Avg. YoY Change vs. 2026 U.S. Avg.
Turkey (16 lb.) $21.09 $19.38 -8% -18%
Stuffing (14 oz.) $3.60 $3.47 -4% -11%
Pumpkin pie filling (30 oz.) $4.02 $3.60 -10% -15%
Pie shells (two 9-in.) $3.66 $2.84 -23% -13%
Sweet potatoes (3 lb.) $3.77 $3.71 -1% -12%
Rolls (1 doz.) $3.50 $3.44 -2% -10%
Frozen peas (16 oz.) $1.80 $1.44 -20% -28%
Whole milk (gal.) $3.05 $3.16 +4% -22%
Fresh cranberries (1 lb.) $2.44 $2.06 -16% -17%
Whipping cream (½ pint) $1.81 $1.62 -10% -12%
Misc. ingredients $3.51 $3.22 -8% -16%
Total $53.62 $49.17 -8% -16%

The Farmer’s Share Hasn’t Budged

Despite lower retail prices, producers’ margins remain under pressure. Farmers receive about 12.6 cents of every retail food dollar, according to USDA estimates cited by the bureau, putting their share of this year’s $49.17 meal at roughly $6.20. Input costs — feed, fuel, fertilizer, labor — have not fallen in step with commodity prices.

“Farmers don’t set the prices,” Davis emphasized. “The amount farmers are being paid doesn’t cover the increase of their input expenses.” The disconnect between farm-gate and retail pricing is a structural feature of modern food supply chains, where processing, transportation, and marketing absorb the bulk of the consumer dollar.

Four-Year Arc: Off the Peak, Still Above Pre-Pandemic

The 2026 basket is 19% below the $61 peak recorded in 2022, when inflation and supply-chain snarls drove holiday costs to a record. Yet it remains 15% above the $42.66 average in 2019, the last pre-COVID Thanksgiving.

Indiana’s discount to the national average has widened. In 2025 the state basket ran about 12% below the U.S. figure; this year the gap is 16%.

What Comes Next

The survey captures prices before most holiday sales activate. Retailers typically deep-discount turkeys and sides in the final week, meaning actual out-of-pocket costs for many shoppers will come in below the $49.17 benchmark.

Indiana Farm Bureau was founded on March 25, 1919, as the Indiana Federation of Farmers’ Associations, one of the first state Farm Bureaus in the nation. It reached 100,000 members in 1952 and became the first to hit 250,000 members in 1977.

The organization operates in all 92 counties and created its Women’s Leadership Committee in 1922, just two years after women won the right to vote; Edna Sewell became the first woman elected to its board in 1923. INFB also founded Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance in 1934, with the first policy sold in February 1935.

For consumers, the 2026 meal is cheaper — but the farmer’s share still buys less feed than it did five years ago.