Columbus police brass are scrambling to explain why the department’s second-in-command kept her job and her gun after leaving a loaded firearm in a public restroom — a lapse that earned rank-and-file officers written reprimands and counseling over the last five years.
First Assistant Chief LaShanna Potts left her division-issued weapon in a first-floor women’s restroom at the Charles D. Shipley Building on West Broad Street on Nov. 3, WOSU Public Media reported. An Ohio State Highway Patrol officer found the gun and returned it; Potts retrieved it within 30 minutes, Chief Elaine Bryant told WZCB-FM 106.7 The Beat on Nov. 12. The city’s Office of the Inspector General opened an investigation the same day.
Disciplinary records obtained by WOSU Public Media show nine officers disciplined since 2019 for lost, stolen or unattended firearms. Five left guns, belts and badges in unlocked vehicles — most were stolen. Two lost their firearms outright. One took a division gun to the Bahamas, where it was confiscated. Another failed to carry a weapon while on duty. None were suspended. All received written reprimands or “documented constructive counseling.”
“Let’s be clear. We’re not dodging accountability. She’s not dodging accountability,” Bryant said on “The City Show,” according to The Columbus Dispatch. “You’d be surprised how often this happens. We’re talking about an agency … of over 2,000 employees.”

The union sees a difference
Fraternal Order of Police Capital City Lodge #9 President Brian Steel disagrees with the chief’s framing. In his 10 years handling disciplinary proceedings and grievances, Steel told The Columbus Dispatch this is the first time he has heard of a gun left unattended in a restroom. He draws a sharp line between theft from a secured vehicle and negligence in a public bathroom.
“I don’t compare a lost and stolen firearm that was secured in a vehicle and they’re a victim of crime… I don’t compare that the same as negligence leaving it in the restroom.”
Steel told The Columbus Dispatch.
Steel said Potts was more negligent than the officers in the records, though not the worst case he has ever seen. “We’re all held to a standard, but the higher you go, the longer you’re on, the more is expected of you,” he told the Dispatch.
He added that he respects Potts and believes she will eventually take ownership, but insisted accountability must apply equally: “All officers, whether a rookie or the chief, should be held accountable.”
Retired deputy chief criticizes department on X
The disparity has drawn public scrutiny. Retired Deputy Chief Ken Kuebler, who left the division in 2023, criticized the department on X for not placing Potts on leave.
He pointed to the case of Deputy Chief Elrico Alli, who spent months relieved of duty after Potts accused him of lying during an investigation into an officer’s conduct. Alli was ultimately cleared; the investigation found he had incorrect information but did not lie, The Columbus Dispatch reported.
Mayor Andrew Ginther declined to comment on Nov. 12, citing the independence of the inspector general’s investigation. Potts, hired alongside Bryant in 2021 after serving as a captain with Detroit police, has no prior disciplinary actions in her Columbus personnel file, WOSU Public Media reported. She continues to perform her regular duties while the investigation proceeds.
Steel told the Dispatch that because the Shipley Building restroom was publicly accessible — though Bryant described it as a secure building — Potts may face more serious punishment than she would for leaving a gun in an employee restroom at a police station, and she might be held to a higher standard given her rank.
- Reporter Argues Real Story of Operation SAFE Begins After Bulldozers Leave
- Gov. Gianforte at 2026 Capitol Christmas Tree Harvest Near Wise River
- Dollar General's Four Test Buys: 30 Price Errors, 21 Against the Shopper (daybreakwire.com)
- General Pants enters voluntary administration putting 500 jobs at risk (newsarchyuk.com)