Iowa Lawmakers Warn Sales Tax Hike for Conservation Trust Requires Political Pledges

On Thursday, Iowa lawmakers at the Iowa Nature Summit warned that funding a long-delayed conservation trust through a sales tax hike will require explicit political pledges to prevent the measure from turning into a damaging campaign weapon.

The discussion centered on filling the Iowa Water and Land Legacy trust, known as IWiLL, which voters approved overwhelmingly in 2010 to support clean water, soil health, and sustainable agriculture. Despite polling from the IWiLL coalition showing that 69% of Iowa voters support raising the state sales tax to fund the trust, the necessary three-eighths of a cent tax increase has stalled for over a decade.

Rep. Chad Ingels, R-Randalia, told the panel that a large portion of his caucus remains resistant to any tax increase. According to the Iowa Department of Revenue, the state’s sale and use tax rate has remained unchanged since 2008.

Ingels predicted that any legislative push would likely bundle the conservation funding into a broader one-cent sales tax increase. He suggested that lawmakers would need to allocate the remaining five-eighths of a cent to reduce tax burdens elsewhere, such as local property taxes or other areas of state government.

Iowa Lawmakers Warn Sales Tax Hike for Conservation Trust Requires Political Pledges
Photo: yahoo.com

“If we increase the sales tax, we’re not going to just increase it three-eighths of a cent to fund the IWiLL,” Ingels said during the summit.

The debate comes on the heels of the Nov. 3 election, where Iowans approved a constitutional amendment making it harder for the Legislature to raise personal and corporate income taxes. Critics of that amendment warned it would force lawmakers to rely on sales taxes and fees to cover state budget deficits.

Newly elected Iowa state Sen. Heather Matson argued that lawmakers must be willing to fund vital public needs like education, healthcare, and natural resources.

“I think what there has not been, in my opinion, the political will of too many elected officials over the last decade or more, to get this done,” Matson said.

“I think that there are a lot of people coming into this Legislature, plus the governor-elect, who care deeply about this, that are going to be willing to have hard conversations within their caucus to get the votes we need to do it.”

Rep. Norlin Mommsen, R-DeWitt, pointed out that the original 2010 ballot measure establishing the trust did not explicitly mention a tax increase. He said that information only appeared in longer explanations posted at election sites.

“Nobody wants to see the postcard in the mail that says Rep. Mommsen raised your sales tax, so kick his ass out of the Legislature,” Mommsen said, explaining the reluctance of lawmakers to touch the issue.

Before entering the Legislature in January 2021 following his election in November 2020, Chad Ingels built a career spanning agriculture, business, and education. A farmer since 1991, he earned a Bachelor of Science in horticulture and a Master of Science in professional agriculture from Iowa State University, later working as a watershed specialist for the university’s extension service from 1999 to 2016.

He also founded ClearWater Ag Strategies, a management firm advising farmers on management strategies, and serves as vice chair of the House Agriculture Committee.

Ingels concurred that moving forward requires a bipartisan pact ensuring the tax increase will not become a political liability. Rep. Kenan Judge, D-Waukee, agreed, emphasizing that legislators must look past party lines and determine how the remaining revenue can help balance future state budgets.