Jason Eaton Files for New Trial, Citing Media Coverage and Jury Issues

Attorneys for Jason Eaton filed a motion for a new trial in Chittenden County Superior Court this month, weeks after a jury convicted him of three counts of attempted murder for shooting three Palestinian American students in Burlington last November.

The filing argues that saturation media coverage and the high-profile nature of the case prejudiced jurors, and that the jury disregarded court instructions on the legal definition of insanity, WCAX reported. Eaton’s legal team specifically cited coverage by several local outlets, including WCAX, as a factor they say compromised the verdict.

Eaton, a Burlington resident, was found guilty in September in connection with the November 25, 2023, shooting of Hisham Awartani, Kinnan Abdalhamid and Tahseen Ahmed. The three men, all 20-year-old college students, were visiting Awartani’s family in Burlington for the Thanksgiving holiday when they were shot on a residential street.

The defense arguments

In the court documents, Eaton’s attorneys contend the volume of press attention made it impossible to seat an impartial jury in Chittenden County. They also assert the jury failed to follow the judge’s instructions regarding the legal standard for insanity, a defense Eaton’s team had pursued at trial.

Burlington Man Convicted in Shooting of Students Seeks New Trial
Photo: vermont-express.com

Throughout the proceedings, Eaton repeatedly requested new counsel, including during the trial itself, and sought to move the case out of Chittenden County. The court denied the venue change request. The state pushed back on the characterization of media coverage, describing it as balanced, according to WCAX.

A judge has scheduled sentencing for January 13, 2027. The court has not yet ruled on the motion for a new trial. It remains unclear how much prison time Eaton could face if the conviction stands.

Sentencing is set for Jan. 13, 2027.