Joanne McNally has defended her appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon after criticism that she should have boycotted the program over its June booking of Conor McGregor.
The Irish comedian, 43, performed a stand-up set on the NBC flagship last month to a standing ovation, but faced pressure on TikTok from female viewers who argued the show had platformed the UFC fighter months after a civil jury found him liable for sexual assault.
“I clapped back and said that if every woman missed out on an opportunity on a show because it had a bad man on the couch, there would be no women working,” McNally told the Press Association.
The controversy traces to November 2024, when a Dublin High Court jury awarded Nikita Hand — also known as Nikita Ní Laimhin — nearly €250,000 in damages after finding McGregor had “brutally raped and battered” her in a Beacon Hotel penthouse suite in December 2018.
McGregor was also ordered to pay approximately €1.3 million in legal costs. He lost his appeal in 2025. Fallon’s June interview, which aired before the appeal verdict, was widely criticized for its light tone; it was described as “soft” on the fighter.
McNally’s rebuttal drew public support from authors and broadcasters. “If women had to boycott all the shows which have platformed misogynists, we’d never be on ANYTHING,” novelist Marian Keyes commented on Instagram. Presenter Roz Purcell called the expectation that a woman sacrifice her career “absolute madness,” while Laura Whitmore wrote, “Finally the booking we all want to see represent us.”
The Fallon factor
Fallon’s booking of McGregor reignited a long-standing debate over late-night gatekeeping. The host has faced prior scrutiny for normalizing controversial figures — most notably the 2016 hair-tussle with Donald Trump — but the McGregor episode landed differently. The civil verdict established liability for sexual violence; the appeal loss cemented it. Yet the show proceeded with a standard promotional segment, avoiding the subject entirely.
McNally’s argument reframes the burden: rather than asking women to withdraw from the few mainstream platforms that exist, she targets the booking apparatus that greenlights “bad men” in the first place.
It is a labor argument dressed in cultural commentary. The Tonight Show remains a singular promotional vehicle for a comic launching a Netflix hour; turning it down on principle would be a luxury few at her stage can afford.
A “fever dream” of momentum
The Fallon set was one node in a compressed run of U.S. exposure. While on tour, McNally taped her debut hour-long Netflix special in New York — a milestone that typically follows years of club work, not a single late-night set.
She also wrapped a semi-final exit on BBC’s The Celebrity Traitors (“I was wrong but strong the whole time in there,” she joked to the Press Association) and filmed a second series of Unacceptable, the TLC panel show hosted by Ed Gamble where she serves as team captain opposite Richard Ayoade.
“I feel very safe in Ed’s hands,” McNally said. “I think if it was left for me and Richard, well, there wouldn’t have been a series one, to be honest.” Gamble, for his part, told the Press Association the second series “was even more fun to film. I think we’re finding our flow a little bit now.”
McNally described the stretch as a “fever dream,” adding she is “not reflective in any way… I’m Irish. We don’t celebrate ourselves; we just get on with it.” She has a memoir under contract but hasn’t delivered it, relying on her iCalendar to reconstruct the timeline.
The platform paradox
The episode illuminates a structural trap: women in entertainment are asked to police the moral hygiene of the stages they didn’t build. McNally’s refusal to boycott — and the industry’s collective shrug at Fallon’s booking — suggests the calculus has shifted. The cost of absence is career stagnation; the cost of presence is online scrutiny. She chose the work.
“Imagine expecting me to turn down an opportunity to do Jimmy Fallon [because] of Conor mc fucking Gregor, surely the man has ruined enough women’s lives,” McNally wrote on Instagram. “I’ll be taking the opportunity.”
Disclaimer: The cultural analyses and financial data presented in this article are based on available public records and industry metrics at the time of publication.