Judge Allows Virginia Beach Holiday Light Show to Open, Denies Rival’s Injunction

“We are disappointed although we really did not want the holidays to be ruined for people,” Adventure Park CEO Bahman Azarm said Friday after a Virginia Beach Circuit Court judge denied his company’s request to shut down a rival city-sponsored light show hours before its opening.

Judge Jonathan Stone ruled Friday morning that the Adventure Park failed to prove its planned Lumi SkyWalk and the city’s Holiday Trail of Lights are similar competitive attractions, allowing the municipal display to open as scheduled at the Virginia Aquarium & Marine Science Center.

The decision came on the very day both attractions were set to debut, capping a frantic legal scramble that played out in court while crews put finishing touches on light displays.

The clash pits a private contractor against the city that owns the land beneath it. Outdoor Ventures, which operates the Adventure Park and the new Lumi SkyWalk through a contract with the aquarium’s foundation, argued the city’s show violates a noncompete clause in a 2021 agreement.

That clause bars “a competing facility of the same type as the Adventure Park” within a 50-mile radius. The company sought a temporary injunction to stop the Holiday Trail of Lights, plus $10 million in lost profits from the city, $10 million in damages from the foundation, and $1 million in damages from IMGoing, the city’s entertainment contractor.

City attorneys countered that the noncompete refers to another ropes course or adventure park — not a holiday light display. “It’s (the aquarium foundation) operating its existing facility with lights and music,” Deputy City Attorney Christopher Boynton told the court.

He noted the city’s former Boardwalk light show operated within that 50-mile radius for 31 years without triggering the clause. The foundation, in a November 13 filing, argued that “nothing in the agreement grants Outdoor Ventures exclusivity over holiday lights, nighttime programming or light displays.”

The Holiday Trail of Lights is scheduled to open Friday in Virginia Beach
Photo: whro.org

Virginia Beach relocated its decades-old Boardwalk display to the aquarium this year, committing $1 million to the new nature-trail format. “We’re gratified the court saw the case as we did,” Boynton said Friday. “We’re very excited the holiday lights will proceed unimpeded.”

The company says it invested heavily in Lumi SkyWalk as a year-round anchor for its Owl Creek Landing operation. CEO Bahman Azarm testified he feared customer confusion and parking congestion if two light shows ran simultaneously on the same campus. “Year one of Lumi SkyWalk is being kneecapped,” attorney Matthew Moynihan argued in court.

Yet the city and foundation raised a threshold issue that may outlive the injunction fight: they contend Outdoor Ventures never secured required approvals to install Lumi SkyWalk in the first place, putting the company in breach of its own contract.

That dispute, along with a separate fight over the height of a 126-foot observation tower the city forced the company to lower citing military security concerns, remains active in the broader lawsuit.

Both shows opened Friday night as planned. The Holiday Trail of Lights winds through the aquarium’s nature trail; Lumi SkyWalk illuminates the tree-top bridges of the Adventure Park a short walk away. For visitors, the litigation is invisible.

The Virginia Aquarium & Marine Science Center opened on June 14, 1986, as the Virginia Marine Science Museum. In 1995, the facility tripled in size, and a 2009 expansion added the Restless Planet exhibits, doubling the number of species displayed. The campus spans two main buildings connected by a one-third mile nature trail alongside Owls Creek Salt Marsh, where the city’s Holiday Trail of Lights is now held.

“We’re definitely on,” Azarm told WHRO on Thursday. “We’re ready.”