Judge Schedules Hearing on Bid to Halt NorthWestern Energy Merger Approval

Montana ratepayers face a utility merger already declared complete while a district judge decides whether the approval process violated the state Constitution.

Lewis and Clark County District Court Judge Kathy Seeley scheduled a hearing for 9 a.m. on Dec. 10 to consider a petition from 350 Montana and the Montana Farmers Union seeking to suspend the Public Service Commission order that cleared the final regulatory hurdle for the NorthWestern Energy and Black Hills Corp. combination.

The utilities announced Monday they had finalized the deal and formed Bright Horizon Energy, a holding company spanning eight states, though the merger remains subject to judicial review and potential reconsideration by the commission.

The consumer and agricultural groups argue the PSC violated Article II, Section 9 of the Montana Constitution when commissioners closed a portion of their final deliberations last Tuesday after Commissioner Randy Pinocci raised a question about potential litigation.

The state charter guarantees the public’s right to observe government proceedings unless individual privacy “clearly exceeds” the merits of disclosure. Attorneys for the petitioners, led by Monica Tranel, contend Montana Supreme Court precedent does not allow exceptions for attorney-client discussions or agency convenience.

Judge Schedules Hearing on Bid to Halt NorthWestern Energy Merger Approval
Photo: fairfieldsuntimes.com

“A stay preserves judicial review,” the parties wrote in their filing. “Without it, the court is not deciding this case later. No one is.”

A PSC spokesperson did not respond to requests for comment Thursday, according to Daily Montanan.

The merger creates one of the largest energy utilities in the region, combining NorthWestern’s Montana and South Dakota footprint with Black Hills’ operations across Wyoming, Colorado, Nebraska, Iowa, Kansas and Arkansas.

Montana was the last state required to sign off on the transaction. The commission approved the deal with conditions intended to protect customers, but the petitioners argue those conditions fail to account for financial risks that could ultimately land on Montana ratepayers.

Tranel, representing the challengers, emphasized the urgency of halting the order before the corporate integration becomes irreversible. The December hearing will determine whether the approval stands while the court examines both the substantive merits of the merger conditions and the procedural question of whether the closed session invalidated the commission’s vote.

NorthWestern Energy traces its Montana roots to the Montana Power Company, which it acquired around 2000 after the state passed legislation allowing the electric utility industry to be unbundled. The company later repurchased the dams originally part of Montana Power for $900 million from PPL Corporation in 2014. Headquartered in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, NorthWestern serves approximately 718,000 customers across Montana, South Dakota and Nebraska as of 2019.

Next step: oral arguments before Judge Seeley at 9 a.m. on Dec. 10 in Lewis and Clark County District Court.