A 19th Judicial District judge will rule Monday on whether to dismiss first- and third-degree rape charges against Desmond Carter, the defendant accused in the 2023 death of LSU student Madison Brooks, after defense attorneys argued that restricted video evidence was leaked to television host Nancy Grace, WAFB reported.
The decision by Judge Gail Horne Ray comes five weeks before Carter’s scheduled Dec. 7 trial and centers on an Oct. 29 episode of Grace’s “Crime Stories” podcast in which she told a guest, “You and I have both seen the video. It’s horrible,” and declared it “very hard to believe… that any of that was consensual.”
Defense attorney Caitlin Fowlkes told the court Thursday that the footage Grace described is classified as contraband by the East Baton Rouge District Attorney’s Office, viewable by defense counsel only during supervised appointments, and that its appearance on a national platform has “irreversibly undermined” Carter’s right to an impartial jury.
The Contraband Classification
Prosecutors have long treated the in-car recordings as contraband under Louisiana law, meaning they cannot be filed publicly or copied by the defense. Attorneys for Carter and co-defendant Casen Carver must travel to the district attorney’s office to view the files on a monitored workstation.
“Contraband cannot be legally possessed by anybody other than the state,” Joe Long, who represents Carver, told WBRZ after a Nov. 4 hearing. “Somebody in the DA’s office gave it to Nancy Grace.”
Long and Fowlkes also contend the original recordings are too dark to discern detail and that only enhanced versions held by the state would have allowed Grace to describe what she saw. The Advocate reported that Fowlkes argued Grace did not merely cover the case but “weighed in on the evidence before either defendant had gone to trial,” prejudicing potential jurors not only in East Baton Rouge Parish but nationwide.
Prosecutors Deny Leak, Cite Prior Public Viewing
District Attorney Hillar Moore flatly denied the allegation. “No one in this office has released any videos to anyone, particularly to any lawyer associated with the victim in this case, or the parents of the victim in this case,” Moore told WAFB earlier this month.
An assistant district attorney pointed to a 2023 press conference where Long and then-attorney Ron Haley stated they had viewed the footage and believed it would disprove the police narrative. Moore characterized the dismissal motion as a baseless delay tactic.
Grace’s program has not responded to requests for comment from WAFB or WBRZ. The Oct. 29 episode, which also featured Brooks’ mother, Ashley Baustert, had garnered more than 156,000 views on YouTube within two weeks, according to WBRZ.
A Change of Venue Won’t Fix This, Defense Says
Fowlkes argued Thursday that moving the trial to another parish would not cure the prejudice because Grace’s commentary reached a national audience. “A change of venue doesn’t work when you’re talking about national news,” she told the court. If the charges are not dismissed, the defense asked that the video evidence and related text messages be excluded from trial.
Carter, who was 17 at the time of the incident and is now 21, faces trial alongside Carver, 22, and Kaivon Washington, 22. A fourth man, Everett Lee, has not been charged with rape.
Authorities say Brooks left Reggie’s Bar in Tigerland with the group in the early hours of Jan. 15, 2023; prosecutors allege she was raped in the back seat of Carver’s vehicle while intoxicated — her blood-alcohol level was .319, per the coroner — then dropped off in a subdivision where she wandered onto Burbank Drive and was struck and killed by a rideshare driver around 2:50 a.m. The defendants are not charged in her death.
Judge Horne Ray said she will issue her ruling Monday.